Article Title: Editorial Roundup: With Syria, situation unpredictable
http://www.lansingstatejournal.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=2013309140010
There are many different opinions about how people think President Obama should respond to what is happening in Syria. The majority of people are against sending our troops in. The president though has just addressed the public saying how it is essential for America to step in and let the Syrian government know that we don't think the use of chemical weapons is okay. President Obama did his best to convince the public that this action is what is best but this editorial shows with syntax, detail and diction how his decision has left him with little support.
In this editorial, the author uses syntax well to show the difficult situation that President Obama is going through. The author uses short sentences when he says, "Obama lost this country" to convey this action more forcefully. By using such a short and direct sentence it gets his point across in a way that gets our attention quickly. Another way the author uses syntax is by using conjunctions to start sentences in order to help us understand the ideas more clearly. He says, "But the news was Obama's confirmation that he has asked Congress to postpone any vote authorizing use of force and will give the diplomats a chance to resolve this." Using "but" to start the sentence helped the readers connect to the situation better.
A second area of rhetoric that this author uses is detail. He does a very nice job of using certain details to show us what is really going on with President Obama and Syria. We see through words such as, "skepticism" and "warily" that nothing is certain and that not even the president is sure of what is going on. I think the author purposely leaves out the details of how actually many Americans do support him in getting involved because the author wants to show the negative side of the story. The details like "it's possible Obama would have a chance at building the international coalition he didn't attempt in the first place." This suggests that the author is criticizing Obama for not trying to build international coalition from the beginning; which has left him with few supporters.
The last area of rhetoric that I will comment on in this editorial is diction. I think the author purposely wrote this in colloquial diction so that everyone could understand what he is saying. He uses negative words like "hopeless," "unpredictable" and "mysterious" to put a negative burden on President Obama. This language he is using brings up mad and upset feelings. It makes most of us angry at Obama for making this decision with Syria. If he would have used words like "promising" and "growth" it would make the public more understanding and support Obama, but by using these negative words it persuades to become angry with the president. It really sends us the message that nothing good is happening and the crisis "will be dramatically different a few days from now."
These three areas of rhetoric help the author emphasize his thoughts and sway us to agree with him. Although it is true that Obama has lost a lot of supporters the use of syntax, details and diction help prove the author's point about that even more.
Katie, you did a nice job of explaining the syntax, detail, and diction in this article. You talked about how the author used short and sentences to get a point across, which really does capture a readers attention much more effectively than long and drawn out sentences tend to so. Your discussion of the details in this piece were very interesting. It surprises me that in a newspaper like LSJ the authors opinions are so obviously shown through the details he both did and did not add. Without directly saying it, but ending the sentence of the example you used with " he didn't attempt in the first place," it is quite clear the authors biased on the topic of the article. Even with the diction you talked about, it sounds like the author carefully chose his diction and was trying to create a negative outlook on the situation with Syria and how Obama is handling it. You did a great job of not just looking at the different rhetoric terms used in this article, but analyzing the effects they had on the readers.
ReplyDeleteHey Katie,
ReplyDeleteJust after reading the first paragraph of this article I definitely think you hit the nail on the head on how the author uses syntax and diction to show the negative perception of President Obama by the public. You did a nice job of a brief summary before you got into the techniques of the articles which was very nice for us commentators, but not strictly necessary. I thing I found interesting was that you didn't comment on the language, which is abundant in this article. Be careful not to mix language and diction up, which you started to do in the last paragraph of evidence. I know I am guilty of this also though, so maybe you should go over any notes and handout we have over the various aspects of DIDLS. You did a great job of using evidence and quotations to prove your point, just remember to both introduce your claims and evidence and then tie them back together, as I believe that is the format we are looking for in this class.
Your essay is very well-organized and does a great job of addressing the prompt. In particular, you were really on the mark in recognizing the voice of the author and how their use of rhetoric contributes to their ideas. I completely agreed with your ideas on the author's diction, and in addition to the air of uncertainty, I think that those words bleed into the author's choice of details. S/he uses those words to contribute to the irresponsible and unprepared image of the administration. However, I was a little confused on your point that the use of "but" in the example sentence connected the readers to the situation. I read it as more of an organization strategy that connected to the previous sentence. Did you think that the author did a good enough job at justifying their viewpoint, or was the article mostly an opinion?
ReplyDeleteHi guys,
ReplyDeleteAbhijit, I totally understand how you think the use of the word "but" as a use of organization. I agree with this but I also think the author used it on purpose to get his point across. Most writers do not usually start sentences with the word "but" which is why I commented on it. Thanks for all your input guys!