Sunday, November 24, 2013

Response to Course Material Nov. 24

Since finishing Death of a Salesman, we started reading Hamlet.  It's longer then the past two plays we have read so it took a lot more time to read, but I have actually found it quite interesting.  Everyday in class we would read it and then Ms. Holmes would stop us and help explain parts of it, which was very helpful.  Without her doing this I would have missed out on some major ideas in the play.  It was also really helpful that I had a book that had the English translation next to the text, since Shakespeare can sometimes be difficult to understand.  While reading Hamlet I often found myself thinking, "Are you kidding me."  In the end they all end up dying, yet that all could have been avoided if people were just honest with each other.  I can relate to this because often times I will try and make things so they will work out for me but if I would have just done nothing, things would have worked out better and instead I made things worse.  Even though Hamlet was kind of crazy I do sympathize with him.  If I lost my father and then my mother married my uncle I would probably act pretty crazy too.  It's hard to sum up how I feel about this play because on one hand I found it entertaining yet I also was so annoyed at times.  It's  mind-blowing to me that Shakespeare could write such amazing plays at that time, that we still read now.

Besides reading and analyzing Hamlet we have also done exercises in class with diction and syntax, where we pick a picture and then write a paragraph about it.  I have found these very insightful because they are really good practice and have been a lot of fun to talk about with my classmates.  We all have different opinions but it is cool that we can all work together to do such an impressive job on these class activities.  We also did an exercise on mood and atmosphere.  Personally this was helpful for me because I am still confused sometimes with mood.  I always associate it with tone but I know now that I should not do that.  One other thing we did was do some more multiple choice practice which is always good practice since ultimately we want to do well on the AP test in May!

It amazes me how much I have learned and grown so far in this class.  I look at literature totally different than I used to and am actually starting to use literary terms to describe pieces of work.  I am excited to do my close reading of Hamlet and see what else I catch when I am reading it for the second time.  Overall I think everyday I am just getting one step closer to being prepared for the AP exam which makes me feel a lot less stressed!

Sunday, November 17, 2013

Open Prompt #3


Prompt:  Choose a novel, or play, write an essay in which you analyze a central question the work raises and the extent to which it offers answers.  Explain how the author's treatment of this question affects your understanding of the work as a whole.  Avoid mere plot summary.

1.  Overall this essay does a very nice job of answering the prompt in an organized and detailed manner.  The student chooses to talk about the novel Candide, which I have never heard of before, but he or she does a nice job of explaining how the author answers the central question of, "Why would God create a world that is not the best possible?" while also adding information from the novel to better help the readers understand.  The student even offers quotes from the books, which is really impressive that he or she could remember the exact quotes without having the book in front of them.  These quotes really add a lot to the idea that the student had a true understanding of the novel.  One thing that the writer could improve on is straying from the topic in the conclusion.  He or she goes on to talking about another book saying, "for as Kahlil Gibrar states in The Prophet loving also entails pain."  Although this may be true, he or she should focus on how the novel he or she choose answers the central question.  Overall this is a pretty impressive essay and I would probably give it an 8!

2.  This student writes about The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.  He or she does a nice job of getting to the point of stating the central question and then talk about how it is answered but the claims are pretty weak.  In the opening paragraph, the student simply states the central question and offers no other thoughts or information.  Yes, he or she answered the question of addressing the central question but it could have been developed a lot better.  For example he or she says, "It is on the raft the Jim and Huff can build a friendship."  Personally I found this essay to just be a summary of the book with a central question thrown in at the beginning and a decent conclusion.  I did not find any evidence that the central question affected his of her understanding of the novel.  Also there are so many mistakes in the essay.  Every other word is crossed out and a new one is written in.  This shows that he or she did not know what he or she wanted to say.  The student should have spent more time organizing his or her ideas before starting the essay.  Overall this essay does address the prompt but fails to offer a good explanation of the central question.  I would give it a 4.

3.  This last essay could definitely use a lot of help.  The student wrote about the novel Things Fall Apart but does not even mention a central question.  Considering the prompt asks you to analyze the central question, the student could not receive a good score even if the essay was written really well.  Let me just tell you though it is not well written.  The student made very vague claims such as, "whether they were small or major changes, they always happen."  First of all the grammar in this sentence does not make sense and also there are no references from the book after this to back it up.  I found myself quite frustrated while reading this essay because the grammar was so bad and there was no organization.  This essay also only has one body paragraph with very few details and it is hard to receive a good score with such little analysis.  Overall I do not think the student had a good understanding of the prompt or the novel he or she was talking about.  Because of the lack of analysis and failure to answer the prompt, I would give it a 2.  

Monday, November 11, 2013

Death of a Salesman


Theme Statement: Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman suggests society’s superficial ideas of success do not always match that of the individual and the denial of one’s true desires can lead to catastrophic consequences.

Setting: The play is set in 1940 in Brooklyn.  Most scenes take place at the house or various places around the city.

Characters:

Willy Loman:  An insecure, traveling salesman who believes the success and wealth come easy but he never achieves it.  He has illusions of his dead brother Ben but some question if he is even real.  Most of the things he says are lies and his mental health begins to unravel. 

Biff Loman: Biff is Willy’s first son who is now in his 30’s.  He was a football star in high school with scholarship offers but he failed math so he didn’t go to college.  Willy is obsessed with Biff being a successful businessman but Biff dreams of moving out West to work with his hands.

Linda Loman: Linda is Willy’s loyal and loving wife.  She goes along with Willy’s dreams even though she knows that he is going crazy.  She attempts to keep the family together and gets mad at Happy and Biff when they insult Willy.

Happy Loman: Happy is Biff’s younger brother who has lived in Biff’s shadow his entire life.  He is always looking for praise from Willy but Willy is always concentrated on Biff.  Willy always says he is going to get married yet he sleeps with many girls.

Charley: Charley is the next-door neighbor who owns a successful business and gives Willy money to pay back his bills.

Bernard: Bernard is Charley’s son and a successful lawyer.  Willy used to mock Bernard for studying but Bernard always offered to help Biff.

Ben: Ben is Willy’s wealthy older brother who died but Willy views him as a symbol of success.

Plot: The play starts out with a flute melody playing and Willy returning home from another failed sales trop.  Linda tries to persuade him to ask his boss to let him work in New York so he won’t have to travel.  Happy and Biff are home and begin to realize that there father is going crazy.  Biff fantasizes about buying a home out west.  There is a flashback to when Biff was a football star and Bernard offers to help Biff pass math but they all just laugh at him.  Willy in the kitchen has an illusion of Ben.  Willy daydreams of Ben’s success and thinks getting rich is as simple as going to Africa.  Biff tells Linda how Willy is a fake (he knows how Willy cheated on her)  but does not tell Linda the truth when she questions him.  Linda tells the boys how Willy has been trying to kill himself.  Biff and Willy get the idea to go into business together to make their father happy and goes to ask Bill Oliver for a loan.  Willy is excited to meet Biff and Willy for dinner.  He goes to ask Howard about working in New York but Howard is too focused on his new tape recorder.  Howard fires Willy and this is the “death of the salesman.”  Willy is furious and is jealous that Bernard has been successful but Biff hasn’t.  Willy asks Charley for more money and Charley offers him a job but he refuses to take it.  At dinner Biff is nervous about telling Willy how he didn’t even get to meet with Bill Olivier and Happy tells him to just lie.  Biff however gets frustrated and Willy and Biff leave Willy at the restaurant.  In the bathroom there is the flashback of Willy’s affair and Biff walking in and losing all respect for his father.  Back at home Linda is furious at them for leaving Willy and Willy is consulting Ben about a 20,000 proposition.  Willy speeds away in the car and kills himself.  In the requiem Biff says how Willy had the wrong dreams and decides to go west.  Happy decides to stay in New York and become a salesman and Linda begs for forgiveness.  The flute melody is played as curtain falls.

Tone: The tone Biff and Willy give off is angry, impatient and frustrated.  Linda’s tone is somewhat helpless.  Willy’s tone is also very desperate.  Happy’s tone is longing for approval from Willy.

Point of View:  Willy is typical everyday man searching for the American dream.  His “death” came long before his actual death. 

Imagery: The readers see imagery of Africa=success.  There is also the imagery of going West being a bad dream to have.

Symbolism: 
Seeds- representing Willy’s opportunity to prove his worth.
Diamonds- representing wealth
Stockings- betrayal and sexual infidelity
Tape Recorder- representing the change in Willy's life through technology and the end of his job.
Trophy/football- represent success.

Motifs:
Mythic Figures- Willy comparing Biff and Happy to Adonis and Hercules
                             - Willy trying to achieve heroic status
West and Alaska- Alaska symbolizes Willy’s failure but the West symbolizes Biff’s                                             potential.
Success comes easily- Willy just keeps asking for the secret to success.
                                   -Willy doesn’t think he has to work hard to be successful
Contradictions- Willy says Biff is lazy but then says he is amazing
                          -Willy says how he hates the car but then says how he loves it
                          -Willy doesn’t have any real opinions for himself
Significant Quotes:
“He's liked, but he's not well liked”  -Willy
-Willy always talks about how he is well liked and this line is used a lot.  He has this want for everyone to like him and to be this super successful man

“I realized what a ridiculous lie my whole life had been.”  -Biff
-Biff realizing that his father’s illusions for success are just that and that he needs to live his own life.
  

Sunday, November 10, 2013

Close Reading #3


http://www.lansingstatejournal.com/article/20131102/OPINION01/311020015/Editorial-roundup-NSA-eroded-trust-U-S-allies

This is an article about the US being caught spying of "three dozen world leaders" (Herald.)  Everyone has heard different things about what actually happened and how much President Obama knew about it, but the truth is hard to find.  The author uses specific details, eye-opening imagery and short sentences (syntax) to inform the public of the sad but true facts about this.

The author is not afraid to report all of the details on this topic.  It allows the audience to understand the actual facts and knowing these facts makes the US government look pretty bad.  Before reading this article many Americans may not have thought it was that big of a deal but when everyone reads details such as, "the White House at first denied the accusations. Then it offered a belated mea culpa that admitted little and satisfied few" (Herald.)  To find out that the government at first tried to lie about this and then just admitted little is shocking.  These details have caused many Americans to lose trust in the government.

The author’s use of imagery hits the readers even more than even the details.  The author does an impressive job of painting an image in the readers’ minds of how big of a deal this spying actually is.  Two sentences that really sticks out is when the author says, “Consider how Americans would react if they discovered that Germany tapped President Obama’s cellphone or that France monitored millions of Americans’ phone calls. We would demand action and accountability, just as they have demanded from us” (Herald.)  This is such a true statement hits home hard.  It’s crazy to think of the outrage that would happen if Americans discovered people were listening in on Americans’ calls.  This imagery does a great job allowing the public to understand the truth and basically putting them against the government.

Lastly the author’s use of syntax with a lot of short sentences displays action, which makes the readers feel like the information is that much more important.  When the author makes short intense statements, its shocks the readers and forces the readers to continue reading since the readers cannot believe what has just been said.  A great example of this is when the author says, “Edward Snowden is a traitor” and “Edward Snowden is a heroic leaker” (Herald.)  These short sentences also help the author show the “he-said, she-said” that is going on right now.  People are saying many different things and Americans have had trouble discovering the actual truth.  By the author writing these short and such accusatory sentences that make the readers read on, the author can then write the truth later on that makes most Americans furious.

The authors use of harsh but true details, intense imagery and short intense sentences force the readers to realize what a big dealt this is and how bad it is that the government tried to cover it up.  Without these uses of techniques the readers may not have thought it was that outrageous and just kept allowing the government to do these things without calling the government out for what has been done.