So it is officially break...yay! We have to do this response to course material so I figured I might as well just get it done. I think the last time I posted a response like this we had just started with Hamlet. I remember thinking that I was never going to have a good understanding of it and the class discussions would not be as good since less people understand it. I now know that I was wrong though. With the help of Ms. Holmes clueing us in on some important background information or things we would have missed we have ended up having some really interesting discussions. We have also watched I think about 6 different versions of Hamlet. I liked different things about different ones. I cannot remember what the versions were called but I really liked the ones where the ghost was portrayed as real. I always saw the ghost as real and good, not evil. I really enjoyed the modern version though since it was something I could relate to better and understand. It was still cool to see the versions that went right off the text to though since that is how it would have been performed originally. We did spend quite a lot of time watching these films but I felt like it was very beneficiary. It allowed us to think about things like how important sticking to the original text is and if the ghost is real. Overall I really enjoyed Hamlet. Yes, it was a tragedy but I really felt for Hamlet since I do not think anyone could really understand what he was going through. He was my favorite character even though he did kinda go crazy.
Besides spending most of our time watching and discussing Hamlet, we have done a few other activities. We talked about how Shakespeare took ideas from ancient stories such as Amleth. This story had many similarities to Hamlet and we even realized that if you stick the h at the end of Amleth in the front it spells Hamlet...that's so crazy!! I guess even the greatest of writers do not come up with everything on their own:) We also had a homework reading and annotating the article "Tragic Balance in Hamlet." The next day while discussing this we found that the writer trying to use such elevated diction kind of took away from the ideas that he was trying to say. I agreed with him on some things like the idea of faith but a lot of his ideas I found to be confusing.
Well I am sure I might have missed an activity or two that we have done but those are the important things that I can remember. Okay now I can go enjoy my break:)
Sunday, December 22, 2013
Sunday, December 15, 2013
Open Prompt Dec. 15
The prompt for question 3, the "open" question, began by defining a symbol as "an object, action, or event that represents something or creates a range of associations beyond itself. Students were asked to select a novel or play, to focus on one symbol, and to write an essay analyzing how the symbol functions in the work; students were then asked to analyze what the symbol reveals about characters or themes in the work as a whole.
Sample 3A:
Wow, this essay was very impressive. He or she talked about the play, The Wild Duck. I have never heard of this play but after reading this essay I felt like I had a really good understanding of it. The student included so many details and did a great job of answering the prompt. The first paragraph is kind of vague and the handwriting is pretty hard to read so I was expecting it to be a weaker essay, but then it goes to such organized, accurate body paragraphs. I can tell the student truly has a good understanding of the play when he says, "Greggers himself actually casts the symbol." It is sometimes hard to think of people being a symbol but this is a great example of this. It was also impressive that the student offered so much evidence from the play to back up what he is saying. For instance he says, "she takes a gun and goes to kill the duck, but commits suicide instead." The student could have just talked about the symbol but by going into detail about the play it makes the symbol more believable.
Sample 3B:
In this essay about the play A Streetcar Named Desire, the student answers the prompt right away saying, "Williams uses a lampshade to symbolize covering up the truth." Yes, this does answer the prompt but very little detail it giving to back up this claim. At the end it does talk a little about how this contributes to the book's meaning but is not that well organized. It is a pretty long essay with a lot of details but not many of them help back up his or her assertion about the lampshade. This essay was given a 6. I would have given it a 5 because I think the analysis was a little underdeveloped. I can see why it was given a six though since it does answer the whole prompt and provide other analysis. Some details such as, "the lampshade symbolizes her fantastical and unreal view of things" contradict what she said originally about the lampshade symbolizing covering up the truth. When I think about it though this essay is probably better than what I could write right now since these can be so hard under a time limit!
Sample 3C:
This is a pretty average essay. It starts out pretty poor but improves a little as it goes on. He or she shows an adequate understanding of the machete being a symbol for power in the novel Things Fall Apart. The student does a nice job of writing about multiple different reasons for the machete being a symbol for power and strength. For instance he or she says, "Okonkwo used his machete on many occasions," "Okonkwo never let a woman touch his blade," and "the machete is used for defense purposes." The essay was given a 4 and that is probably what I would give it as well. It answers the prompt, backing up the claims pretty well but doesn't go above and beyond and does not show how the machete contributes to the book's meaning. He or she does do a really nice job of organizing his or her ideas and expressing his or her thoughts in a well written essay though.
Sample 3A:
Wow, this essay was very impressive. He or she talked about the play, The Wild Duck. I have never heard of this play but after reading this essay I felt like I had a really good understanding of it. The student included so many details and did a great job of answering the prompt. The first paragraph is kind of vague and the handwriting is pretty hard to read so I was expecting it to be a weaker essay, but then it goes to such organized, accurate body paragraphs. I can tell the student truly has a good understanding of the play when he says, "Greggers himself actually casts the symbol." It is sometimes hard to think of people being a symbol but this is a great example of this. It was also impressive that the student offered so much evidence from the play to back up what he is saying. For instance he says, "she takes a gun and goes to kill the duck, but commits suicide instead." The student could have just talked about the symbol but by going into detail about the play it makes the symbol more believable.
Sample 3B:
In this essay about the play A Streetcar Named Desire, the student answers the prompt right away saying, "Williams uses a lampshade to symbolize covering up the truth." Yes, this does answer the prompt but very little detail it giving to back up this claim. At the end it does talk a little about how this contributes to the book's meaning but is not that well organized. It is a pretty long essay with a lot of details but not many of them help back up his or her assertion about the lampshade. This essay was given a 6. I would have given it a 5 because I think the analysis was a little underdeveloped. I can see why it was given a six though since it does answer the whole prompt and provide other analysis. Some details such as, "the lampshade symbolizes her fantastical and unreal view of things" contradict what she said originally about the lampshade symbolizing covering up the truth. When I think about it though this essay is probably better than what I could write right now since these can be so hard under a time limit!
Sample 3C:
This is a pretty average essay. It starts out pretty poor but improves a little as it goes on. He or she shows an adequate understanding of the machete being a symbol for power in the novel Things Fall Apart. The student does a nice job of writing about multiple different reasons for the machete being a symbol for power and strength. For instance he or she says, "Okonkwo used his machete on many occasions," "Okonkwo never let a woman touch his blade," and "the machete is used for defense purposes." The essay was given a 4 and that is probably what I would give it as well. It answers the prompt, backing up the claims pretty well but doesn't go above and beyond and does not show how the machete contributes to the book's meaning. He or she does do a really nice job of organizing his or her ideas and expressing his or her thoughts in a well written essay though.
Sunday, December 8, 2013
Close Reading Dec. 8th
Michelle Obama, mom in chief
In this article, the author defends Michelle Obama of
exhibiting “frightening behaviors” (Milbank). The New York Times reported that she has been “derided by
critics who hoped she would use her historic position to move more deeply into
policy.” The author used comical
diction, specific syntax and interesting details to show how even though the
First Lady is spending most of her time talking about gingerbread houses that
that is the smart choice.
Milbank’s use of comical diction allow the readers to
understand how crazy it is that the First Lady is more worried about decorating
the White House than making an actual impact while she has the power. Many would have expected her to try to make
a change now that her husband has been reelected but instead she is taking on
the conventional role of playing “mom.”
The author uses words such as, “hullabaloo” and “debacle” to describe
what would happen if she “install(ed) herself as a lightening rod atop the
White House” (Milbank). The author
could have chosen to use serious words to describe why the First Lady might not
be trying to make use of her power but instead he goes along with the story by
using funny words since all the things she has been doing are comical.
Milbank uses specific syntax to sway the readers into
understanding the situation that Mrs. Obama is in. In the beginning of the article he uses short sentences such
as, “the feminist nightmare is reoccurring” to cue the readers into what the
First Lady is being portrayed as.
Later on in the article when he is defending her actions and explaining
why she is acting like an old-fashioned woman, longer sentences are used. Short sentences portray action and
excitement. When readers start to
read the article it forces them to continue reading since they are so intrigued
by these short intense sentences.
Once the author has gotten the reader to read on, he can use long
sentences such as, “were she to follow her critics’ advice now that her husband is safely
reelected and install herself as a lightning rod atop the White House, the
resulting hullabaloo would sap whatever focus remains on the Obama policy
agenda.” These longer sentences do
a better job of explaining the situation to the readers.
Lastly the author uses interesting details to get the
readers hooked on the story and then make it seem like Mrs. Obama has no other
choice but to act as mom in chief.
The author could have decided not to include the details about all the
crazy things she has been doing recently to help him defend her but instead he
reports on these items and then gives rational explanations. This makes the article seem more
creditable since it shows all the facts.
For example when he writes, “she spoke of Christmas trees made from
stacks of books and described the first dog display featuring likenesses of Bo
and Sunny” the readers are astonished at how ridiculous that is but then by
including more details later in the article about how she has to play this role
readers are more likely to understand.
The author’s impressive use of comical diction, specific
syntax and interesting details used let the readers feel like they are hearing
the whole truth while also being persuaded that this is what the First Lady
should be doing.
Sunday, November 24, 2013
Response to Course Material Nov. 24
Since finishing Death of a Salesman, we started reading Hamlet. It's longer then the past two plays we have read so it took a lot more time to read, but I have actually found it quite interesting. Everyday in class we would read it and then Ms. Holmes would stop us and help explain parts of it, which was very helpful. Without her doing this I would have missed out on some major ideas in the play. It was also really helpful that I had a book that had the English translation next to the text, since Shakespeare can sometimes be difficult to understand. While reading Hamlet I often found myself thinking, "Are you kidding me." In the end they all end up dying, yet that all could have been avoided if people were just honest with each other. I can relate to this because often times I will try and make things so they will work out for me but if I would have just done nothing, things would have worked out better and instead I made things worse. Even though Hamlet was kind of crazy I do sympathize with him. If I lost my father and then my mother married my uncle I would probably act pretty crazy too. It's hard to sum up how I feel about this play because on one hand I found it entertaining yet I also was so annoyed at times. It's mind-blowing to me that Shakespeare could write such amazing plays at that time, that we still read now.
Besides reading and analyzing Hamlet we have also done exercises in class with diction and syntax, where we pick a picture and then write a paragraph about it. I have found these very insightful because they are really good practice and have been a lot of fun to talk about with my classmates. We all have different opinions but it is cool that we can all work together to do such an impressive job on these class activities. We also did an exercise on mood and atmosphere. Personally this was helpful for me because I am still confused sometimes with mood. I always associate it with tone but I know now that I should not do that. One other thing we did was do some more multiple choice practice which is always good practice since ultimately we want to do well on the AP test in May!
It amazes me how much I have learned and grown so far in this class. I look at literature totally different than I used to and am actually starting to use literary terms to describe pieces of work. I am excited to do my close reading of Hamlet and see what else I catch when I am reading it for the second time. Overall I think everyday I am just getting one step closer to being prepared for the AP exam which makes me feel a lot less stressed!
Besides reading and analyzing Hamlet we have also done exercises in class with diction and syntax, where we pick a picture and then write a paragraph about it. I have found these very insightful because they are really good practice and have been a lot of fun to talk about with my classmates. We all have different opinions but it is cool that we can all work together to do such an impressive job on these class activities. We also did an exercise on mood and atmosphere. Personally this was helpful for me because I am still confused sometimes with mood. I always associate it with tone but I know now that I should not do that. One other thing we did was do some more multiple choice practice which is always good practice since ultimately we want to do well on the AP test in May!
It amazes me how much I have learned and grown so far in this class. I look at literature totally different than I used to and am actually starting to use literary terms to describe pieces of work. I am excited to do my close reading of Hamlet and see what else I catch when I am reading it for the second time. Overall I think everyday I am just getting one step closer to being prepared for the AP exam which makes me feel a lot less stressed!
Sunday, November 17, 2013
Open Prompt #3
Prompt: Choose a novel, or play, write an essay in which you analyze a central question the work raises and the extent to which it offers answers. Explain how the author's treatment of this question affects your understanding of the work as a whole. Avoid mere plot summary.
1. Overall this essay does a very nice job of answering the prompt in an organized and detailed manner. The student chooses to talk about the novel Candide, which I have never heard of before, but he or she does a nice job of explaining how the author answers the central question of, "Why would God create a world that is not the best possible?" while also adding information from the novel to better help the readers understand. The student even offers quotes from the books, which is really impressive that he or she could remember the exact quotes without having the book in front of them. These quotes really add a lot to the idea that the student had a true understanding of the novel. One thing that the writer could improve on is straying from the topic in the conclusion. He or she goes on to talking about another book saying, "for as Kahlil Gibrar states in The Prophet loving also entails pain." Although this may be true, he or she should focus on how the novel he or she choose answers the central question. Overall this is a pretty impressive essay and I would probably give it an 8!
2. This student writes about The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn. He or she does a nice job of getting to the point of stating the central question and then talk about how it is answered but the claims are pretty weak. In the opening paragraph, the student simply states the central question and offers no other thoughts or information. Yes, he or she answered the question of addressing the central question but it could have been developed a lot better. For example he or she says, "It is on the raft the Jim and Huff can build a friendship." Personally I found this essay to just be a summary of the book with a central question thrown in at the beginning and a decent conclusion. I did not find any evidence that the central question affected his of her understanding of the novel. Also there are so many mistakes in the essay. Every other word is crossed out and a new one is written in. This shows that he or she did not know what he or she wanted to say. The student should have spent more time organizing his or her ideas before starting the essay. Overall this essay does address the prompt but fails to offer a good explanation of the central question. I would give it a 4.
3. This last essay could definitely use a lot of help. The student wrote about the novel Things Fall Apart but does not even mention a central question. Considering the prompt asks you to analyze the central question, the student could not receive a good score even if the essay was written really well. Let me just tell you though it is not well written. The student made very vague claims such as, "whether they were small or major changes, they always happen." First of all the grammar in this sentence does not make sense and also there are no references from the book after this to back it up. I found myself quite frustrated while reading this essay because the grammar was so bad and there was no organization. This essay also only has one body paragraph with very few details and it is hard to receive a good score with such little analysis. Overall I do not think the student had a good understanding of the prompt or the novel he or she was talking about. Because of the lack of analysis and failure to answer the prompt, I would give it a 2.
1. Overall this essay does a very nice job of answering the prompt in an organized and detailed manner. The student chooses to talk about the novel Candide, which I have never heard of before, but he or she does a nice job of explaining how the author answers the central question of, "Why would God create a world that is not the best possible?" while also adding information from the novel to better help the readers understand. The student even offers quotes from the books, which is really impressive that he or she could remember the exact quotes without having the book in front of them. These quotes really add a lot to the idea that the student had a true understanding of the novel. One thing that the writer could improve on is straying from the topic in the conclusion. He or she goes on to talking about another book saying, "for as Kahlil Gibrar states in The Prophet loving also entails pain." Although this may be true, he or she should focus on how the novel he or she choose answers the central question. Overall this is a pretty impressive essay and I would probably give it an 8!
2. This student writes about The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn. He or she does a nice job of getting to the point of stating the central question and then talk about how it is answered but the claims are pretty weak. In the opening paragraph, the student simply states the central question and offers no other thoughts or information. Yes, he or she answered the question of addressing the central question but it could have been developed a lot better. For example he or she says, "It is on the raft the Jim and Huff can build a friendship." Personally I found this essay to just be a summary of the book with a central question thrown in at the beginning and a decent conclusion. I did not find any evidence that the central question affected his of her understanding of the novel. Also there are so many mistakes in the essay. Every other word is crossed out and a new one is written in. This shows that he or she did not know what he or she wanted to say. The student should have spent more time organizing his or her ideas before starting the essay. Overall this essay does address the prompt but fails to offer a good explanation of the central question. I would give it a 4.
3. This last essay could definitely use a lot of help. The student wrote about the novel Things Fall Apart but does not even mention a central question. Considering the prompt asks you to analyze the central question, the student could not receive a good score even if the essay was written really well. Let me just tell you though it is not well written. The student made very vague claims such as, "whether they were small or major changes, they always happen." First of all the grammar in this sentence does not make sense and also there are no references from the book after this to back it up. I found myself quite frustrated while reading this essay because the grammar was so bad and there was no organization. This essay also only has one body paragraph with very few details and it is hard to receive a good score with such little analysis. Overall I do not think the student had a good understanding of the prompt or the novel he or she was talking about. Because of the lack of analysis and failure to answer the prompt, I would give it a 2.
Monday, November 11, 2013
Death of a Salesman
Theme Statement:
Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman
suggests society’s superficial ideas of success do not always match that of the
individual and the denial of one’s true desires can lead to catastrophic
consequences.
Setting: The play
is set in 1940 in Brooklyn. Most
scenes take place at the house or various places around the city.
Characters:
Willy Loman:
An insecure, traveling salesman who believes the success and wealth come
easy but he never achieves it. He
has illusions of his dead brother Ben but some question if he is even
real. Most of the things he says
are lies and his mental health begins to unravel.
Biff Loman: Biff is Willy’s first son who is now in
his 30’s. He was a football star
in high school with scholarship offers but he failed math so he didn’t go to
college. Willy is obsessed with
Biff being a successful businessman but Biff dreams of moving out West to work
with his hands.
Linda Loman: Linda is Willy’s loyal and loving
wife. She goes along with Willy’s
dreams even though she knows that he is going crazy. She attempts to keep the family together and gets mad at
Happy and Biff when they insult Willy.
Happy Loman: Happy is Biff’s younger brother who has
lived in Biff’s shadow his entire life.
He is always looking for praise from Willy but Willy is always
concentrated on Biff. Willy always
says he is going to get married yet he sleeps with many girls.
Charley: Charley is the next-door neighbor who owns a
successful business and gives Willy money to pay back his bills.
Bernard: Bernard is Charley’s son and a successful
lawyer. Willy used to mock Bernard
for studying but Bernard always offered to help Biff.
Ben: Ben is Willy’s wealthy older brother who died
but Willy views him as a symbol of success.
Plot: The play
starts out with a flute melody playing and Willy returning home from another
failed sales trop. Linda tries to
persuade him to ask his boss to let him work in New York so he won’t have to
travel. Happy and Biff are home
and begin to realize that there father is going crazy. Biff fantasizes about buying a home out
west. There is a flashback to when
Biff was a football star and Bernard offers to help Biff pass math but they all
just laugh at him. Willy in the
kitchen has an illusion of Ben.
Willy daydreams of Ben’s success and thinks getting rich is as simple as
going to Africa. Biff tells Linda
how Willy is a fake (he knows how Willy cheated on her) but does not tell Linda the truth when
she questions him. Linda tells the
boys how Willy has been trying to kill himself. Biff and Willy get the idea to go into business together to
make their father happy and goes to ask Bill Oliver for a loan. Willy is excited to meet Biff and Willy
for dinner. He goes to ask Howard
about working in New York but Howard is too focused on his new tape
recorder. Howard fires Willy and
this is the “death of the salesman.”
Willy is furious and is jealous that Bernard has been successful but
Biff hasn’t. Willy asks Charley
for more money and Charley offers him a job but he refuses to take it. At dinner Biff is nervous about telling
Willy how he didn’t even get to meet with Bill Olivier and Happy tells him to
just lie. Biff however gets
frustrated and Willy and Biff leave Willy at the restaurant. In the bathroom there is the flashback
of Willy’s affair and Biff walking in and losing all respect for his
father. Back at home Linda is
furious at them for leaving Willy and Willy is consulting Ben about a 20,000
proposition. Willy speeds away in
the car and kills himself. In the
requiem Biff says how Willy had the wrong dreams and decides to go west. Happy decides to stay in New York and
become a salesman and Linda begs for forgiveness. The flute melody is played as curtain falls.
Tone: The tone
Biff and Willy give off is angry, impatient and frustrated. Linda’s tone is somewhat helpless. Willy’s tone is also very
desperate. Happy’s tone is longing
for approval from Willy.
Point of View: Willy is typical everyday man searching
for the American dream. His
“death” came long before his actual death.
Imagery: The
readers see imagery of Africa=success.
There is also the imagery of going West being a bad dream to have.
Symbolism:
Seeds- representing Willy’s opportunity to prove his worth.
Diamonds- representing wealth
Stockings- betrayal and sexual infidelity
Tape Recorder- representing the change in Willy's life through technology and the end of his job.
Trophy/football- represent success.
Motifs:
Motifs:
Mythic Figures- Willy comparing Biff and Happy to Adonis and
Hercules
- Willy trying to achieve heroic status
West and Alaska- Alaska symbolizes Willy’s failure but the
West symbolizes Biff’s potential.
Success comes easily- Willy just keeps asking for the secret
to success.
-Willy doesn’t think he has to work hard
to be successful
Contradictions- Willy says Biff is lazy but then says he is
amazing
-Willy says how he hates the car but
then says how he loves it
-Willy doesn’t have any real opinions
for himself
Significant Quotes:
“He's
liked, but he's not well liked” -Willy
-Willy
always talks about how he is well liked and this line is used a lot. He has this want for everyone to like
him and to be this super successful man
“I realized
what a ridiculous lie my whole life had been.” -Biff
-Biff
realizing that his father’s illusions for success are just that and that he
needs to live his own life.
Sunday, November 10, 2013
Close Reading #3
http://www.lansingstatejournal.com/article/20131102/OPINION01/311020015/Editorial-roundup-NSA-eroded-trust-U-S-allies
This is an article about the US being
caught spying of "three dozen world leaders" (Herald.) Everyone
has heard different things about what actually happened and how much President
Obama knew about it, but the truth is hard to find. The author uses
specific details, eye-opening imagery and short sentences (syntax) to inform
the public of the sad but true facts about this.
The author is not afraid to report all of
the details on this topic. It allows the audience to understand the
actual facts and knowing these facts makes the US government look pretty bad.
Before reading this article many Americans may not have thought it was
that big of a deal but when everyone reads details such as, "the White
House at first denied the accusations. Then it
offered a belated mea culpa that admitted little and satisfied few"
(Herald.) To find out that the government at first tried to lie about
this and then just admitted little is shocking. These details have caused many Americans to lose trust in
the government.
The author’s use of imagery
hits the readers even more than even the details. The author does an impressive job of painting an image in
the readers’ minds of how big of a deal this spying actually is. Two sentences that really sticks out is
when the author says, “Consider how Americans would
react if they discovered that Germany tapped President Obama’s cellphone or
that France monitored millions of Americans’ phone calls. We would demand
action and accountability, just as they have demanded from us” (Herald.) This is such a true statement hits home
hard. It’s crazy to think of the
outrage that would happen if Americans discovered people were listening in on
Americans’ calls. This imagery
does a great job allowing the public to understand the truth and basically
putting them against the government.
Lastly the author’s use of syntax
with a lot of short sentences displays action, which makes the readers feel
like the information is that much more important. When the author makes short intense statements, its shocks
the readers and forces the readers to continue reading since the readers cannot
believe what has just been said. A
great example of this is when the author says, “Edward Snowden is a traitor”
and “Edward Snowden is a heroic leaker” (Herald.) These short sentences also help the author show the “he-said,
she-said” that is going on right now.
People are saying many different things and Americans have had trouble
discovering the actual truth. By
the author writing these short and such accusatory sentences that make the
readers read on, the author can then write the truth later on that makes most
Americans furious.
The authors use of harsh but true
details, intense imagery and short intense sentences force the readers to
realize what a big dealt this is and how bad it is that the government tried to
cover it up. Without these uses of
techniques the readers may not have thought it was that outrageous and just
kept allowing the government to do these things without calling the government
out for what has been done.
Wednesday, October 23, 2013
Response to Course Material #2
Since reading and discussing The American Dream we have read Death
of a Salesman. While watching
the movie I did not find the story line that entertaining or interesting at
all. I even started to wonder why
we were even reading the book. But
once I actually got a chance to read the book and analyze it I found myself
loving it. I caught on to all of
these implications and foreshadowing that I did not while I was watching the
movie. I have been much more
involved in the discussion of this book then normal because I felt like I
understood it a lot more than The
American Dream. I feel like I
can relate a lot to Biff because although my dad is not insane he can be pretty
annoying and sometimes I just want to get away. When I was younger I idolized my dad like Biff did but as I
got older I realized he was not perfect, just as Biff did. I also did a lot better on my
annotations of the book because now that we are pretty far along in the year I
know the literary terms a lot better and I can actually apply them. This is pretty cool for me
because I feel like I have learned so much and am also enjoying the class a
lot.
Besides just reading Death
of A Salesman, we have also done a close reading of the poem Promises Like Piecrust. I really enjoyed this poem because I
feel like it is so true. Promises
are broken most of the time and it is scary to jump into a commitment. I do think that you should take the
risk and make commitments though.
I try not to live my life in fear and understand that I am going to get
hurt at some point. Overall this
was a really fun poem to talk about since everyone had such different opinions
about it. Going along
with this poem we got to write AP essay prompts, which I found to be really eye
opening. I actually found it a
little challenging. It made me
realize how much work goes into just writing the prompt so that they get the response
they want. It was a fun activity
to get to swap them with another group though.
In conclusion over the past few works I feel like I have
really improved and participated more which was my goal. I’m starting to enjoy the class a lot
more and feeling more comfortable with my peers. I am excited to read more books and learning even more. I know that everyday I am getting more
and more prepared for the AP test at the end of the year!
Sunday, October 20, 2013
Open Prompts, Part One. Examples 3A, 3B and 3C
Prompt: Many
writers use a country setting to establish values within a work of
literature. For example, the
country may be a place of virtue and peace or one of primitivism and ignorance. Choose a novel or play in which such a
setting plays a significant role.
Then write an essay in which you analyze how the country setting
functions in the work as a whole.
3A:
This essay is very impressive. Especially after doing a practice prompt I understand how
hard it can be to write these essays.
One of the most important things and also can be the hardest is making
sure you’re answering the prompt and this author does an amazing job of
this. The author also explained a
lot about the book, which I thought was very helpful. I have never read Jane
Austen’s Persuasion but with all the examples I can tell that it works
great with the prompt. She did a
great job of backing up all of her statements with information from the
book. For example she said, “Only
in this country setting is Anne held in a superior light, for her qualities of
intelligence, kindness and modesty are held in high regard here.” This is just such a well-written
sentence and overall it is enjoyable to read. The conclusion does a great job of summing everything up
nicely as well. The only complaint
I would have would be all the grammar errors.
3B:
In this essay we can tell that the author was trying very
hard with lots of different details but he or she failed to find a deeper
meaning to it all. The author says
a lot of important facts such as, “it is written in dialect,” but these
statements fail to relate back to the actual question, which is the most
important thing. Everything said
has to be justified by the question.
However, I know that these are not easy to write and I think he or she came
up with a good example of The Importance
of Being Earnest. It is
also really nicely written and easy to read; which is always a plus considering
some people’s handwritingJ
I think the author could have also done a better job of tying his of her thesis
back into the conclusion, since we want to remember what the author is arguing
for. Overall, it is a pretty
average essay that had some nice components but also could use a lot of
improvement.
3C:
This essay definitely could have been written and
brainstormed better. The
author is almost cocky in the essay thinking that he or she knows everything
without using any evidence to back up all of the claims. There are a lot of details about the
plot, which is helpful but then it started to become more of a summary than an
essay with examples. For instance
the writer says, “Why else would she give herself sexually twice thinking that
the second would reverse the effects of the first?” First of all, this sentence does not even really make sense
and it is assuming a lot of things.
Everyone can have different opinions about topics and this author comes
off as rude. I think he or she is
trying to be funny, which is good sometimes but not throughout the whole
essay. In conclusion this
author had the right idea but needed a lot more focus on the prompt and
examples.
Monday, October 14, 2013
Summary/Analysis of The American Dream
Theme: Edward
Albee’s American Dream warns that the
current generation of Americans has gutted the heart and soul of original
American values and replaced them with a shallow, materialistic longing to
acquire unattainable satisfaction, but there is hope of change.
Characters:
Mommy-shallow, rude, emasculates Daddy, bosses around
Daddy, searching for satisfaction the whole play and at the end believes that
she attains it.
Daddy-had a sex change so he wants to feel masculine,
comes from a lot of money, rarely sticks up to Mommy, and acts very child-like.
Grandma- still has the old American Dream, realizes
that this play is just an act, isn’t afraid to speak the truth and acts point
out that she is “old.”
Mrs. Barker- typical American housewife, sells Mommy
and Daddy their son from “Bye-Bye Adoption Service,” tries to give them
satisfaction, argues about color of hat with Mommy.
Young Man; very attractive, represents new American
Dream, will do anything for money, identical twin of Mommy and Daddy’s son and
Mommy finds satisfaction with him.
Setting: Mommy and Daddy’s apartment living room in the
1960’s.
Plot: Mommy and
Daddy are sitting in the living room of their apartment complaining about how
you can never get satisfaction these days. They have essentially switched gender roles and Daddy even
had a sex change; so he is always looking for confirmation of his masculinity
from Mommy. Grandma has all her
boxes packed up to leave and Mommy and Daddy can’t figure what they are. Mommy threatens that the van man will
come take her away. They are all
waiting for someone to come but never indicate whom they are waiting for. Eventually Mrs. Barker comes and has a
long conversation with Grandma.
Meanwhile Daddy or Mommy can’t find any of Grandma’s belongings or even
her room. We find out that Mrs.
Barker sold Mommy and Daddy their son, but then that Mommy and Daddy killed
it. Then a young man comes looking
for work and representing the new American dream. We find out that he is the identical twin of the son and
Mommy finds satisfaction from him (implying that she is going to sleep with
him.) Grandma exits the play and
talks to the audience suggesting she knows this is all an act. In the end Grandma leaves and we see
hope that the old American Dream is still alive. Overall Albee uses humor to mask that nothing really happens
in the play.
Tone/Point of View:
Albee is trying to point out how materialistic and shallow
Americans have become recently. Most
people these days are just interested in money and fame and less interested in
family. This is seen when Mommy is
so mean to Grandma and threatens to send her away. Also when the young man comes looking for money, it shows
how people do everything for money.
Since it is a play, the tone changes from character to character but
Mommy’s tone is usually bossy and impatient. Daddy’s tone is usually anxious and longing for
assurance. Grandma’s tone is
usually annoyed.
There are quite a few motifs in the play. The first one is gender role swaps;
which is shown with Daddy having a sex change and then Mommy bossing Daddy
around. Another one is childish
behaviors, which is shown by none of them having jobs and Mrs. Barker taking
her dress off. Satisfaction is
another motif shown at the beginning with Mommy’s hat and at the end with the young
boy. The motif of lack of empathy
is shown a lot with everyone always telling Grandma to shut up or that she is
going to be taken away. One last
motif is the transition of American dreams. Grandma represents the old American Dream but she is
leaving. The young boy represents
the new American dream and Mommy is in love with him. We see imagery in the play when they are describing what
Mommy and Daddy did with their son.
We also see imagery when Albee is describing the scenes in great detail.
Significant Quotes:
“And masculine?
Was I really masculine?” –Daddy talking to Mommy pg. 74
This quote is significant because throughout the whole play
we see the struggle of Daddy wanting satisfaction that he is a man since Mommy
has emasculated him so much. He is
always looking for assurance from Mommy.
This relates to the motif of gender swaps.
“You’re the American Dream, that’s what you are." –Grandma
talking to the young man pg. 108
This quote is important because it represents the transition
of the old American dream to the new American dream. The young man represents the new American dream since he is
good looking and after money.
Everyone falls in love with him, showing how all of our old values are
changing.
Saturday, October 12, 2013
Close Reading #2
Article: It’s Not Only Mothers and Children
In the editorial, It’s Not Only Mothers and Children,
the author writes how normally people think of families being in poverty
because the parents are unable to provide for the kids when in reality most
of the people living in poverty are childless adults. The author explains how difficult it is to get Medicaid
these days and how it needs to be extended to childless, low-income adults but
many Republican states are not agreeing to this.
The author’s use of long sentences, specific details and colloquial
diction give a strong feeling that something needs to be done to help all of
the childless adults, living in poverty that do not qualify for Medicaid.
The author’s use of long sentences force the audience to
keep reading. Although sometimes
people can get bored with long sentences the author does a nice job of mixing
in some average size sentences to not let the readers get too lost. Since the article is about such a
serious topic, using long sentences was definitely the best choice since the
author needed to put in so much information. The author starts off the article saying, “for impoverished
Americans, the biggest obstacle to health insurance remains the refusal of 26
mostly Republican-led states to expand their Medicaid programs as called for
under the health reform law.” This
is a mouth full to take in but is eye opening to the audience to read. Using long sentences was ultimately the
reason this editorial came off as so informative and persuasive, since the long
sentences were so well written.
The author’s use of specific details allows the readers to
assume that the author knows the actual facts and that the information must be
true. By using details such as, “most, however, are childless adults,
generally defined as those age 19 to 64 without dependent children.” This sentence suggests that the author
actually did a lot of research for the article, which makes the readers agree
with what is being said, since it seems legitimate. Also the fact that the author uses such harsh details about
the Republicans not wanting to add the reform makes the audience sympathize
with the childless adults living in poverty even more. Without this use of such harsh and
specific details the author would not have nearly as many people agreeing with
him.
Lastly the
author’s use of colloquial diction makes this a very easy article to understand
and read. Sometimes when such high
language is used people will get confused and not want to read an article. With everyday language being used
though, everyone is willing to read it and does not get lost or bored. The author knew to get the point across
that simple yet detailed sentences would be best. This colloquial diction also makes the readers feel more
involved in the issue.
Overall,
without the authors use of long sentences, specific details and colloquial
diction this article would not be effective. These were great techniques to use to allow the public to be
more educated about this issue.
The techniques also make everyone want to do something about the matter.
Sunday, September 29, 2013
Response to Course Material Sept. 29
In the beginning of the school year we learned the important things to comment on when annotating and what to look for when doing a close reading. This was very helpful to me because I took British Literature and we never had to do that. We also reviewed and learned many literary terms that are essential to knowing in this class. In fact, I am going to go back and play the review games again with those terms to make sure that I know them. We spent a few days going over DIDLS- diction, imagery, details, language and syntax. We practiced finding these elements in different readings and those were the first times I've only looked for one aspect of a writing while reading. It was crazy to see how much thought authors put into creating the perfect piece of writing. Now I actually understand how different styles and techniques of writing create different tones and moods of the writing.
After reviewing all of these, we started to read the play The American Dream and talking about existentialism and the Theatre of the Absurd. The American Dream portrayed many elements of existentialism and the Theatre of the Absurd in the way that the humor masked the fact that the play was basically about nothing. We have had many class discussions about this play and what we think the deeper meaning behind it is. I think these discussions have been very helpful to allow everyone to better understand the play. We have also read differing essays about the play that have changed some of our views about the play and lead to better class discussions. For instance, when we read about whether this play is pro-feminist or anti-feminist many people in the class had different ideas. We can all interpret the text in different ways and I think that is one of the most important things I have learned so far. I now know that it is okay to disagree and that maybe the reading does not have one specific meaning. I have now started to annotate The American Dream which has added to my understanding of the play even more, as I'm reading it for the second time. Overall I really like this play and I have found it very interesting to think about the actual American dream changing. I would say that for most people it has changed. We live in a world where it is every man for himself. Power and money have now become the new American Dream.
Sunday, September 22, 2013
Open Prompts Part One Samples LLLL, C and FF
Sample LLLL,
I think the writer addressed the prompt very well and
the flow of the essay was great! I
thought their example of Jay Gatsby was creative, yet also one that everyone can
relate to since most people have read it.
I also liked all of the details he or she included about The Great Gatsby to back up all of your statements with
evidence. The essay, itself, is
pretty pleasant to read as well.
It has varied sentence structure and it is written in colloquial diction
so we can tell you are the true voice of the essay. I think the author does stray a little from the prompt though
when he or she starts summarizing what happens in the book. Yes, most of the details of the book
are needed and good details but some are not relevant and not adding to the
success of the essay. Overall, it
is a very nicely written essay that does an awesome job of answering the
question and that is the most important thing. The writer picked a great character, Jay Gatsby, and backed it up with
great examples; which is often hard to do.
Sample C,
I think the writer did a nice job of picking an example and describing what he or she meant by it. I have never read King Lear and I feel like I got a pretty good idea of what it was all about and about the tragic flaws of him. I think the author's organization was a little hard to follow at times and I felt like he or she could have gone more in depth about how exactly he is a tragic figure. We are given some examples like how his “pride” and “ego” are tragic but many people have these flaws. I think there could have been some more explanation on that. I do think though that the writer did an amazing job of painting a picture of the story in our minds. The details he or she used were very descriptive and helpful in understanding. I think in general the author answered the question and did a decent job of explaining her or himself but I think with a little more planning the organization could have improved and thus improving the flow of the essay.
I think this writer did a nice job of taking a position and understanding the prompt, but he or she definitely could have done a better job of providing evidence. The first paragraph is also very underdeveloped and this is the first thing that people read, so it gave the essay a bad start. I already didn't think the essay was that good by just reading the first paragraph. I also think he or she could have picked a different example with a character that was without a doubt a tragic character. I think some would argue McMurphy wasn't all that bad and also brought the characters joy. So when picking an example the author should make sure it is one to easily back up with solid evidence. The writer also had a lot of mistakes in his or her writing that were scribbled out that distracted me from reading and caused me to get lost. He or she should try to be more careful next time since the author is writing in pen. Overall, I think the writer understood the prompt and answered it, but I think there was minimal evidence which made the essay very basic.
Sunday, September 15, 2013
Close Reading #1
Article Title: Editorial Roundup: With Syria, situation unpredictable
http://www.lansingstatejournal.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=2013309140010
There are many different opinions about how people think President Obama should respond to what is happening in Syria. The majority of people are against sending our troops in. The president though has just addressed the public saying how it is essential for America to step in and let the Syrian government know that we don't think the use of chemical weapons is okay. President Obama did his best to convince the public that this action is what is best but this editorial shows with syntax, detail and diction how his decision has left him with little support.
In this editorial, the author uses syntax well to show the difficult situation that President Obama is going through. The author uses short sentences when he says, "Obama lost this country" to convey this action more forcefully. By using such a short and direct sentence it gets his point across in a way that gets our attention quickly. Another way the author uses syntax is by using conjunctions to start sentences in order to help us understand the ideas more clearly. He says, "But the news was Obama's confirmation that he has asked Congress to postpone any vote authorizing use of force and will give the diplomats a chance to resolve this." Using "but" to start the sentence helped the readers connect to the situation better.
A second area of rhetoric that this author uses is detail. He does a very nice job of using certain details to show us what is really going on with President Obama and Syria. We see through words such as, "skepticism" and "warily" that nothing is certain and that not even the president is sure of what is going on. I think the author purposely leaves out the details of how actually many Americans do support him in getting involved because the author wants to show the negative side of the story. The details like "it's possible Obama would have a chance at building the international coalition he didn't attempt in the first place." This suggests that the author is criticizing Obama for not trying to build international coalition from the beginning; which has left him with few supporters.
The last area of rhetoric that I will comment on in this editorial is diction. I think the author purposely wrote this in colloquial diction so that everyone could understand what he is saying. He uses negative words like "hopeless," "unpredictable" and "mysterious" to put a negative burden on President Obama. This language he is using brings up mad and upset feelings. It makes most of us angry at Obama for making this decision with Syria. If he would have used words like "promising" and "growth" it would make the public more understanding and support Obama, but by using these negative words it persuades to become angry with the president. It really sends us the message that nothing good is happening and the crisis "will be dramatically different a few days from now."
These three areas of rhetoric help the author emphasize his thoughts and sway us to agree with him. Although it is true that Obama has lost a lot of supporters the use of syntax, details and diction help prove the author's point about that even more.
http://www.lansingstatejournal.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=2013309140010
There are many different opinions about how people think President Obama should respond to what is happening in Syria. The majority of people are against sending our troops in. The president though has just addressed the public saying how it is essential for America to step in and let the Syrian government know that we don't think the use of chemical weapons is okay. President Obama did his best to convince the public that this action is what is best but this editorial shows with syntax, detail and diction how his decision has left him with little support.
In this editorial, the author uses syntax well to show the difficult situation that President Obama is going through. The author uses short sentences when he says, "Obama lost this country" to convey this action more forcefully. By using such a short and direct sentence it gets his point across in a way that gets our attention quickly. Another way the author uses syntax is by using conjunctions to start sentences in order to help us understand the ideas more clearly. He says, "But the news was Obama's confirmation that he has asked Congress to postpone any vote authorizing use of force and will give the diplomats a chance to resolve this." Using "but" to start the sentence helped the readers connect to the situation better.
A second area of rhetoric that this author uses is detail. He does a very nice job of using certain details to show us what is really going on with President Obama and Syria. We see through words such as, "skepticism" and "warily" that nothing is certain and that not even the president is sure of what is going on. I think the author purposely leaves out the details of how actually many Americans do support him in getting involved because the author wants to show the negative side of the story. The details like "it's possible Obama would have a chance at building the international coalition he didn't attempt in the first place." This suggests that the author is criticizing Obama for not trying to build international coalition from the beginning; which has left him with few supporters.
The last area of rhetoric that I will comment on in this editorial is diction. I think the author purposely wrote this in colloquial diction so that everyone could understand what he is saying. He uses negative words like "hopeless," "unpredictable" and "mysterious" to put a negative burden on President Obama. This language he is using brings up mad and upset feelings. It makes most of us angry at Obama for making this decision with Syria. If he would have used words like "promising" and "growth" it would make the public more understanding and support Obama, but by using these negative words it persuades to become angry with the president. It really sends us the message that nothing good is happening and the crisis "will be dramatically different a few days from now."
These three areas of rhetoric help the author emphasize his thoughts and sway us to agree with him. Although it is true that Obama has lost a lot of supporters the use of syntax, details and diction help prove the author's point about that even more.
Friday, August 9, 2013
Poetry Practice-Second Entry
After working through these poetry problems I realized I really need a lot more practice with poetry. It is definitely my weakest subject. In particular I really struggle with figuring out the big picture that the poem is trying to get at. I think I try to read the poems literally instead of trying to figure out the symbolism in the poem. I have figured out that it takes me reading it a couple times to catch all the symbolism. I think while I am reading poetry I have to have no distractions or else I will totally miss what is really going on. Overall, I think if I really focus on not just reading the words and actually reading the poem as one whole story, then I will understand the poems better!
Diagnostic Multiple Choice Test Reflection-First Entry
While taking the Diagnostic test many things surprised me. At the beginning, in the first piece of poetry about a lover who must leave on a journey, I did not understand it was about that at first. For me I really have to read poetry a couple times before I understand what is going on. When I read the second section of reading on Pride and Prejudice it reconfirmed about what I thought about my reading skills. I am definitely better at reading and understand writing that is in novel from than poetry. The questions on Pride and Prejudice were a lot easier for me to answer than the ones on the first piece of poetry. I do though need to make sure I am really paying attention when I read because on the question that as about the irony in Pride and Prejudice I totally did not get. When I got the answer wrong and went back to read read it then I realized I had totally missed that Mr. Bennet's description of his wife's nerves. He calls her nerves his "old friends."
When I came to the poem Night Clouds I thought it might be easy to understand since it was so short. I then thought how dumb I was to think that since sometimes the shortest poems are the hardest to interpret. I found that this was true with this poem. It really confused me. I understood that it was about a partly cloudy dawn, but I also found it kind of boring. On the last section to read I felt pretty confident about my reading skills because I had no problem answering all the questions and got almost all of them right.
Overall taking this diagnostic test was really good for me to be able to see where I am with reading comprehension. I struggled with some things but I didn't think it was too bad. It did kind of scare me at how much your brain checks out over the summer though!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)