So it is officially break...yay! We have to do this response to course material so I figured I might as well just get it done. I think the last time I posted a response like this we had just started with Hamlet. I remember thinking that I was never going to have a good understanding of it and the class discussions would not be as good since less people understand it. I now know that I was wrong though. With the help of Ms. Holmes clueing us in on some important background information or things we would have missed we have ended up having some really interesting discussions. We have also watched I think about 6 different versions of Hamlet. I liked different things about different ones. I cannot remember what the versions were called but I really liked the ones where the ghost was portrayed as real. I always saw the ghost as real and good, not evil. I really enjoyed the modern version though since it was something I could relate to better and understand. It was still cool to see the versions that went right off the text to though since that is how it would have been performed originally. We did spend quite a lot of time watching these films but I felt like it was very beneficiary. It allowed us to think about things like how important sticking to the original text is and if the ghost is real. Overall I really enjoyed Hamlet. Yes, it was a tragedy but I really felt for Hamlet since I do not think anyone could really understand what he was going through. He was my favorite character even though he did kinda go crazy.
Besides spending most of our time watching and discussing Hamlet, we have done a few other activities. We talked about how Shakespeare took ideas from ancient stories such as Amleth. This story had many similarities to Hamlet and we even realized that if you stick the h at the end of Amleth in the front it spells Hamlet...that's so crazy!! I guess even the greatest of writers do not come up with everything on their own:) We also had a homework reading and annotating the article "Tragic Balance in Hamlet." The next day while discussing this we found that the writer trying to use such elevated diction kind of took away from the ideas that he was trying to say. I agreed with him on some things like the idea of faith but a lot of his ideas I found to be confusing.
Well I am sure I might have missed an activity or two that we have done but those are the important things that I can remember. Okay now I can go enjoy my break:)
Sunday, December 22, 2013
Sunday, December 15, 2013
Open Prompt Dec. 15
The prompt for question 3, the "open" question, began by defining a symbol as "an object, action, or event that represents something or creates a range of associations beyond itself. Students were asked to select a novel or play, to focus on one symbol, and to write an essay analyzing how the symbol functions in the work; students were then asked to analyze what the symbol reveals about characters or themes in the work as a whole.
Sample 3A:
Wow, this essay was very impressive. He or she talked about the play, The Wild Duck. I have never heard of this play but after reading this essay I felt like I had a really good understanding of it. The student included so many details and did a great job of answering the prompt. The first paragraph is kind of vague and the handwriting is pretty hard to read so I was expecting it to be a weaker essay, but then it goes to such organized, accurate body paragraphs. I can tell the student truly has a good understanding of the play when he says, "Greggers himself actually casts the symbol." It is sometimes hard to think of people being a symbol but this is a great example of this. It was also impressive that the student offered so much evidence from the play to back up what he is saying. For instance he says, "she takes a gun and goes to kill the duck, but commits suicide instead." The student could have just talked about the symbol but by going into detail about the play it makes the symbol more believable.
Sample 3B:
In this essay about the play A Streetcar Named Desire, the student answers the prompt right away saying, "Williams uses a lampshade to symbolize covering up the truth." Yes, this does answer the prompt but very little detail it giving to back up this claim. At the end it does talk a little about how this contributes to the book's meaning but is not that well organized. It is a pretty long essay with a lot of details but not many of them help back up his or her assertion about the lampshade. This essay was given a 6. I would have given it a 5 because I think the analysis was a little underdeveloped. I can see why it was given a six though since it does answer the whole prompt and provide other analysis. Some details such as, "the lampshade symbolizes her fantastical and unreal view of things" contradict what she said originally about the lampshade symbolizing covering up the truth. When I think about it though this essay is probably better than what I could write right now since these can be so hard under a time limit!
Sample 3C:
This is a pretty average essay. It starts out pretty poor but improves a little as it goes on. He or she shows an adequate understanding of the machete being a symbol for power in the novel Things Fall Apart. The student does a nice job of writing about multiple different reasons for the machete being a symbol for power and strength. For instance he or she says, "Okonkwo used his machete on many occasions," "Okonkwo never let a woman touch his blade," and "the machete is used for defense purposes." The essay was given a 4 and that is probably what I would give it as well. It answers the prompt, backing up the claims pretty well but doesn't go above and beyond and does not show how the machete contributes to the book's meaning. He or she does do a really nice job of organizing his or her ideas and expressing his or her thoughts in a well written essay though.
Sample 3A:
Wow, this essay was very impressive. He or she talked about the play, The Wild Duck. I have never heard of this play but after reading this essay I felt like I had a really good understanding of it. The student included so many details and did a great job of answering the prompt. The first paragraph is kind of vague and the handwriting is pretty hard to read so I was expecting it to be a weaker essay, but then it goes to such organized, accurate body paragraphs. I can tell the student truly has a good understanding of the play when he says, "Greggers himself actually casts the symbol." It is sometimes hard to think of people being a symbol but this is a great example of this. It was also impressive that the student offered so much evidence from the play to back up what he is saying. For instance he says, "she takes a gun and goes to kill the duck, but commits suicide instead." The student could have just talked about the symbol but by going into detail about the play it makes the symbol more believable.
Sample 3B:
In this essay about the play A Streetcar Named Desire, the student answers the prompt right away saying, "Williams uses a lampshade to symbolize covering up the truth." Yes, this does answer the prompt but very little detail it giving to back up this claim. At the end it does talk a little about how this contributes to the book's meaning but is not that well organized. It is a pretty long essay with a lot of details but not many of them help back up his or her assertion about the lampshade. This essay was given a 6. I would have given it a 5 because I think the analysis was a little underdeveloped. I can see why it was given a six though since it does answer the whole prompt and provide other analysis. Some details such as, "the lampshade symbolizes her fantastical and unreal view of things" contradict what she said originally about the lampshade symbolizing covering up the truth. When I think about it though this essay is probably better than what I could write right now since these can be so hard under a time limit!
Sample 3C:
This is a pretty average essay. It starts out pretty poor but improves a little as it goes on. He or she shows an adequate understanding of the machete being a symbol for power in the novel Things Fall Apart. The student does a nice job of writing about multiple different reasons for the machete being a symbol for power and strength. For instance he or she says, "Okonkwo used his machete on many occasions," "Okonkwo never let a woman touch his blade," and "the machete is used for defense purposes." The essay was given a 4 and that is probably what I would give it as well. It answers the prompt, backing up the claims pretty well but doesn't go above and beyond and does not show how the machete contributes to the book's meaning. He or she does do a really nice job of organizing his or her ideas and expressing his or her thoughts in a well written essay though.
Sunday, December 8, 2013
Close Reading Dec. 8th
Michelle Obama, mom in chief
In this article, the author defends Michelle Obama of
exhibiting “frightening behaviors” (Milbank). The New York Times reported that she has been “derided by
critics who hoped she would use her historic position to move more deeply into
policy.” The author used comical
diction, specific syntax and interesting details to show how even though the
First Lady is spending most of her time talking about gingerbread houses that
that is the smart choice.
Milbank’s use of comical diction allow the readers to
understand how crazy it is that the First Lady is more worried about decorating
the White House than making an actual impact while she has the power. Many would have expected her to try to make
a change now that her husband has been reelected but instead she is taking on
the conventional role of playing “mom.”
The author uses words such as, “hullabaloo” and “debacle” to describe
what would happen if she “install(ed) herself as a lightening rod atop the
White House” (Milbank). The author
could have chosen to use serious words to describe why the First Lady might not
be trying to make use of her power but instead he goes along with the story by
using funny words since all the things she has been doing are comical.
Milbank uses specific syntax to sway the readers into
understanding the situation that Mrs. Obama is in. In the beginning of the article he uses short sentences such
as, “the feminist nightmare is reoccurring” to cue the readers into what the
First Lady is being portrayed as.
Later on in the article when he is defending her actions and explaining
why she is acting like an old-fashioned woman, longer sentences are used. Short sentences portray action and
excitement. When readers start to
read the article it forces them to continue reading since they are so intrigued
by these short intense sentences.
Once the author has gotten the reader to read on, he can use long
sentences such as, “were she to follow her critics’ advice now that her husband is safely
reelected and install herself as a lightning rod atop the White House, the
resulting hullabaloo would sap whatever focus remains on the Obama policy
agenda.” These longer sentences do
a better job of explaining the situation to the readers.
Lastly the author uses interesting details to get the
readers hooked on the story and then make it seem like Mrs. Obama has no other
choice but to act as mom in chief.
The author could have decided not to include the details about all the
crazy things she has been doing recently to help him defend her but instead he
reports on these items and then gives rational explanations. This makes the article seem more
creditable since it shows all the facts.
For example when he writes, “she spoke of Christmas trees made from
stacks of books and described the first dog display featuring likenesses of Bo
and Sunny” the readers are astonished at how ridiculous that is but then by
including more details later in the article about how she has to play this role
readers are more likely to understand.
The author’s impressive use of comical diction, specific
syntax and interesting details used let the readers feel like they are hearing
the whole truth while also being persuaded that this is what the First Lady
should be doing.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)