Sunday, September 22, 2013

Open Prompts Part One Samples LLLL, C and FF


  Sample LLLL,

I think the writer addressed the prompt very well and the flow of the essay was great!  I thought their example of Jay Gatsby was creative, yet also one that everyone can relate to since most people have read it.  I also liked all of the details he or she included about The Great Gatsby to back up all of your statements with evidence.  The essay, itself, is pretty pleasant to read as well.  It has varied sentence structure and it is written in colloquial diction so we can tell you are the true voice of the essay.  I think the author does stray a little from the prompt though when he or she starts summarizing what happens in the book.  Yes, most of the details of the book are needed and good details but some are not relevant and not adding to the success of the essay.  Overall, it is a very nicely written essay that does an awesome job of answering the question and that is the most important thing.  The writer picked a great character, Jay Gatsby, and backed it up with great examples; which is often hard to do.

Sample C,

I think the writer did a nice job of picking an example and describing what he or she meant by it.  I have never read King Lear and I feel like I got a pretty good idea of what it was all about and about the tragic flaws of him.  I think the author's organization was a little hard to follow at times and I felt like he or she could have gone more in depth about how exactly he is a tragic figure.  We are given some examples like how his “pride” and “ego” are tragic but many people have these flaws.  I think there could have been some more explanation on that.  I do think though that the writer did an amazing job of painting a picture of the story in our minds.  The details he or she used were very descriptive and helpful in understanding.  I think in general the author answered the question and did a decent job of explaining her or himself but I think with a little more planning the organization could have improved and thus improving the flow of the essay.



 Sample FF,

I think this writer did a nice job of taking a position and understanding the prompt, but he or she definitely could have done a better job of providing evidence.  The first paragraph is also very underdeveloped and this is the first thing that people read, so it gave the essay a bad start.  I already didn't think the essay was that good by just reading the first paragraph.  I also think he or she could have picked a different example with a character that was without a doubt a tragic character.  I think some would argue McMurphy wasn't all that bad and also brought the characters joy.  So when picking an example the author should make sure it is one to easily back up with solid evidence.  The writer also had a lot of mistakes in his or her writing that were scribbled out that distracted me from reading and caused me to get lost.  He or she should try to be more careful next time since the author is writing in pen.  Overall, I think the writer understood the prompt and answered it, but I think there was minimal evidence which made the essay very basic.

3 comments:

  1. Katie, I think you had very good responses to the essays. With the first essay, while I did not read it, I like how you pointed out the varied sentence structure and colloquial diction. Having varied sentence structure can make a piece flow much more smoothly than having all short and choppy sentences or all very lengthy sentences. Also, I think often times people try to put very big and flowery words in an essay where they are unnecessary to try to make them sound more intelligent, so using colloquial diction can be more effective in getting the point of an essay across. In the second essay, it sounds like the student may have done just that. Like you said, without an organized structure to begin with, the piece cannot be fixed by just using a descriptive word choice. With the third essay, I agree with you that providing evidence is so important. Without evidence a claim is just a claim with nothing to back it up. Did you find that any of the issues you found in the essays you analyzed helped you when you were writing an essay for yourself?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Katie,
    I notice you commented on your chosen essays in the second person, addressing the writers as "you." I think it's great that you took a informal approach to reviewing, practicing for peer review in our classes, but it is probably not what this assignment is looking for, since we don't actually know the writers of these essays. I found it interesting that you found some of the same critiques as the official graders, which means you must be looking at the pieces in the right way. I agree that the first essay seems to wander into the dangerous territory of plot summarization, but also think that the syntax is at times more formal than colloquial, which is what you said it was. In general the scoring of the three essays seemed to increase the more evidence that was given to support their claim, as like you said the third essay did not support its thesis very well. Do you think that as we start to write open prompt essays we should try to add lots of evidence in, or would that be toeing the line of simply summarizing the work?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Katie,
    Your analysis of this prompt was very well done! I agree with your point that evidence is necessary to arguments because otherwise, they are just baseless opinions. I was wondering if you noticed how the essay writers were able to tie their analysis of the characters back to the meaning of the text. In the "no. 1" prompt that I read, the writer was very clear on the meaning of the story he wrote about, so did you feel that way about any of these essays? In choosing details, do you think that it is more important to give the reader a good context for the story and your explanation, or should every detail be specific and linked to a certain claim in the essay? I really liked your point on the broad nature of the second writer's claims. Those nonspecific terms did not relate anything that the character did back to the specific story, and the writer should have elaborated more on the character's role and effect in the text. Great work.
    P.S.I also found pen scribbles to be a problem!

    ReplyDelete