Sunday, December 15, 2013

Open Prompt Dec. 15

The prompt for question 3, the "open" question, began by defining a symbol as "an object, action, or event that represents something or creates a range of associations beyond itself.  Students were asked to select a novel or play, to focus on one symbol, and to write an essay analyzing how the symbol functions in the work; students were then asked to analyze what the symbol reveals about characters or themes in the work as a whole.

Sample 3A:
Wow, this essay was very impressive.  He or she talked about the play, The Wild Duck.  I have never heard of this play but after reading this essay I felt like I had a really good understanding of it.  The student included so many details and did a great job of answering the prompt.  The first paragraph is kind of vague and the handwriting is pretty hard to read so I was expecting it to be a weaker essay, but then it goes to such organized, accurate body paragraphs.  I can tell the student truly has a good understanding of the play when he says, "Greggers himself actually casts the symbol."  It is sometimes hard to think of people being a symbol but this is a great example of this.  It was also impressive that the student offered so much evidence from the play to back up what he is saying.  For instance he says, "she takes a gun and goes to kill the duck, but commits suicide instead."  The student could have just talked about the symbol but by going into detail about the play it makes the symbol more believable.

Sample 3B:
In this essay about the play A Streetcar Named Desire, the student answers the prompt right away saying, "Williams uses a lampshade to symbolize covering up the truth."  Yes, this does answer the prompt but very little detail it giving to back up this claim.  At the end it does talk a little about how this contributes to the book's meaning but is not that well organized.  It is a pretty long essay with a lot of details but not many of them help back up his or her assertion about the lampshade.  This essay was given a 6.  I would have given it a 5 because I think the analysis was a little underdeveloped.  I can see why it was given a six though since it does answer the whole prompt and provide other analysis.  Some details such as, "the lampshade symbolizes her fantastical and unreal view of things" contradict what she said originally about the lampshade symbolizing covering up the truth.  When I think about it though this essay is probably better than what I could write right now since these can be so hard under a time limit!

Sample 3C:
This is a pretty average essay.  It starts out pretty poor but improves a little as it goes on.  He or she shows an adequate understanding of the machete being a symbol for power in the novel Things Fall Apart.  The student does a nice job of writing about multiple different reasons for the machete being a symbol for power and strength.  For instance he or she says, "Okonkwo used his machete on many occasions," "Okonkwo never let a woman touch his blade," and "the machete is used for defense purposes."  The essay was given a 4 and that is probably what I would give it as well.  It answers the prompt, backing up the claims pretty well but doesn't go above and beyond and does not show how the machete contributes to the book's meaning.  He or she does do a really nice job of organizing his or her ideas and expressing his or her thoughts in a well written essay though.

3 comments:

  1. Katie, great job anaylzing each of these articles and clearly stating your opinion of the thoroughness and greatness of each essay. The first essay sounds as though it was very detailed, but avoided just summarizing, but did a great job of explaining the main symbol. I find it interesting the symbol was a person, I have a hard time thinking of another novel or story when the main character or one of the character's acts as a symbol. However, there are no definite symbols in stories so perhaps I have just not picked up on any in previous works I have read. I will sure to be more conscious of that now though. The second and third essay are clearly not as strong as the first. In the second you explain that although the essay was long, it still failed to do a solid job of answering the prompt, I have noticed this to be a common trend among students while reading these essays and think it is definitely something to be cautious of when we go to write our essays. Overall great job on these essays, I think as we do this more and more it really helps us to understand what a decent essay is and what the AP graders are looking for.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Katie,
    I liked your second two paragraphs the best. They used many quotes, and you showed rather than told what you did or didn’t like about the essays. I think your first essay paragraph could use some work though. First off, you didn’t really show why the essay was good. I did like when you said that it helped you understand a play that you haven’t read before, but I want to know more details! I want to know why you thought it was so good, and I want to know what this writer got. What do you think it deserved? I know you did this with the other two, but its important to all of them. I don’t want to bring you down, because the second two paragraphs were basically flawless, just do what you did to those two, to the first one, and you’ve got an a plus blog post!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Katie,
    I remember reading this set of essays some time back, and what sticks in my mind the most is the last one, which I thought was quite poorly written. You wrote that this was an average essay, though in my mind an average essay is closer to the second example. I would have to disagree with you on that point, for I would rank this essay well below average. When I read the work, I thought it was not only unfocused but poorly organized, with ideas shoved every which-way in paragraphs that held no internal continuity. But, that is merely what I read it as; and I guess that the author did attempt an answer at the prompt. If we are struggling at an essay (which I know I have done many times before), it's always best to attempt an answer to the best of your ability, which could be the reason for the low quality of this essay.

    ReplyDelete