Sunday, January 12, 2014

Open Prompt, Part 2 Jan. 12


A symbol is an object, action, or event that represents something or that creates a range of associations beyond itself.  In literary works a symbol can express an idea, clarify meaning, or enlarge literal meaning.  Select a novel or play and, focusing on one symbol, write an essay analyzing how that symbol functions in the work and what it reveals about the characters or themes of the work as a whole.

In Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman, Alaska, Africa and the West is a major symbol.  These three places are mentioned quite often through out the play.  These are all places unknown to the Loman family since they have always lived in the same place but they all symbolize wealth and opportunity.  Willy and Biff seem to think that going to these places will give them success.

In the beginning of the play Willy’s brother, Ben is talking to Willy about how he went to Africa, found a diamond mine and became rich.  He then tells Willy that he is off to Alaska to look at properties.  Willy always thought you became rich in the big city so he is astonished to think that wealth can be found in these random places.  Willy daydreams of what it would be like if he went to Alaska with Ben.  He now associates Alaska with success and wealth, thinking that becoming rich is as easy as moving to Alaska.  The readers all know that success comes from working hard and there is not just a key to it.  To Willy though, Alaska and Africa symbolize the success and freedom he has never had living in New York.

Similar to Willy, Biff also dreams of a different life.  Willy wants Biff to become a successful businessman and pushes him to do that but Biff has different thoughts.  Biff has always wanted to move West and work on a farm.  Biff is very unhappy in New York and believes that moving west is the key to happiness.  Again there is this idea that by moving to some obscure place you will be successful.  It is like people say the grass is always greener on the other side.  This fits perfectly because Biff really has no idea or actual plan about the west but he somehow just associates it with a better life.  In the end Biff decides to actually move West but the readers never know how that works out. 

The one big difference between Biff and Willy is that Biff understands that being successful is not just about being rich it is about being happy.  A major theme in this play is the American Dream and becoming successful and Alaska, Africa and the West all symbolize that in different ways.  Whenever these places are mentioned in the play they symbolize to the readers the dreams that Willy and Biff have (even though Willy’s dreams are totally different from Biff’s dreams.)   By the author using these obscure places to express the theme of the American Dream, the readers can better understand what it is that Biff and Willy actually want.

3 comments:

  1. Hi Katie,

    Very well done! You've thoroughly convinced me that unknown lands of opportunity are used as an effective symbol throughout Death of a Salesman! I really liked how you noted the subtle differences in the use of each of these locations--I would've just lumped them all together haha.

    The only thing I feel like I'm missing is a bit more elaboration on how the use of Alaska, Africa, and the West affects Miller's message in the play. You touched on the theme of DoS being related to "the American Dream and becoming successful," but I'd say that's more of a motif than a theme statement like the ones we debate on in class. I don't know how the time limit worked out for you (I came pretty close to using all 40 minutes) but if I were you, I would have kept it going from that point, delving (Ros and Guil) more into what Miller says and how the thought of a new life elsewhere helps that point get across.

    Keep up the great work!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Katie,

    To start off, there are a few grammatical errors that do interrupt my reading of your essay. Grammar is easily fixed though, so there shouldn’t be too much to worry about; I’d just fix that before these posts are graded. Aside from that, it seems like your introduction is missing a complete thesis statement. Having a nicely developed thesis is an important aspect for the writing section on the AP exam, and I believe it even has its own category on the rubric (it’s been awhile since I’ve looked at the rubric, but pretty much all writing sections on a formal test like this ask for a good thesis).

    Overall, I think that you are able to get the idea of Alaska, Africa, and the West being symbols across, but your essay is lacking in technique. Maybe the time limit got to you, or maybe you weren’t exactly in the essay-writing mood. There needs to be a bit more variation in sentence length and better transitions between paragraphs. Sorry if my comment sounds harsh, I just feel that these are areas that you should take the time to look at and improve upon.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Katie,
    You did a good job on the first open prompt part 2! The symbols you chose, Alaska, Africa and the west for Death of a Salesman are not something I would have initially understood, but you did a great job of explaining it in your essay and I can now see why these are such great symbols. You did a great job of addressing all the parts of the prompt, and discussed both what the symbols reveal about the characters and themes of Death of a Salesman as a whole. You might have been able to expand upon your idea a little bit more by adding another body paragraph and going even further in depth about these symbols. For this being the first of these blog posts and with time constraints, this is very impressive, and I think with a little editing and elaboration this post will be great!

    ReplyDelete