Prompt: Choose a novel, or play, write an essay in which you analyze a central question the work raises and the extent to which it offers answers. Explain how the author's treatment of this question affects your understanding of the work as a whole. Avoid mere plot summary.
In Shakespeare's Hamlet, a central question was will Hamlet relinquish control of himself? There are so many different forces such as the Ghost, his religious views and his actual thoughts that are affecting his ideas. Hamlet struggles throughout the play of not knowing whether to kill Claudius, but in the end even though he does end up killing Claudius he did not end up relinquishing control of himself.
In the beginning of the play the Ghost appears telling Hamlet that Claudius killed him and to avenge his death by killing Claudius. Hamlet at first decides to listen to the ghost and kill Claudius but later begins to have other thoughts. Hamlet has the perfect chance to kill Claudius while he is praying but he decides not to. This shows how Hamlet does have some control of himself at this point and is not just letting the Ghost control him. Later though while Hamlet is with his mother he thinks that Claudius is listening behind the curtain and stabs him. It was actually Polonius though and so he kills Polonius. This shows how Hamlet does allow the Ghost to influence him now and he ends up killing an innocent man. At the beginning of the play Hamlet battles with whether or not to allow the Ghost to control him.
Another force that was taking control of Hamlet is his religious views. Yes, Hamlet is furious and wants to kill Claudius but then he starts to wonder if the Ghost is good or evil. Hamlet is cautious towards the Ghost because of his Christian beliefs which makes the plan to avenge his father's death a little harder. Hamlet is at a loss of what to do. By not killing Claudius when he has the chance does show though that religion is a major influence in his life. According to his beliefs any ghost was evil, yet Hamlet does listen to the Ghost and kills Polonius because of it. By even talking to the Ghost it goes against his religion. This shows how even though his religious beliefs are strong at some points, they do not totally define him and he does not relinquish control to God.
The last answer to the central question is Hamlet's own morals and thoughts. In the end Hamlet Shakespeare does a good job of showing how Hamlet does not relinquish control of himself. Hamlet goes into the fight not being scared of death. Hamlet does not just believe the Ghost and puts on the play to see if Claudius is really guilty. When Claudius becomes angry and leaves it gives Hamlet the proof that he did kill his father. Knowing that Claudius is guilty he makes his own decision without the influence of the Ghost or his religious beliefs and kills Hamlet. This ultimately is the best thing since it rid Denmark of this corrupt family. Hamlet felt comfortable knowing Fortinbras was taking over since that was the best thing for everyone. The last scene shows how Hamlet takes matters into his own hand and does not let anyone or anything control him.
Overall, there are a lot of people and things that are influencing Hamlet and his actions. Hamlet struggled a lot throughout the play not knowing what to do but in the end the question of: Will Hamlet relinquish control? is answered by Hamlet making his own choices and taking control of his life. Unfortunately, he was hit with the poisoned sword but he does the right thing by killing Claudius and not just giving up on his life. Hamlet did not relinquish control to providence, the Ghost or anyone else in his life...even though they are all trying to influence him.
Hi Katie,
ReplyDeleteSolid open prompt. You have great organization to your essay, with linking sentences between each paragraph. Your introduction and conclusion are great -- filled with sentences with purpose, rather than fluff. My main critique would be that you didn't answer part of the prompt. You analyzed a central question in itself, "Will Hamlet relinquish control over himself?", but you didn't really relate it to the work as a whole. How did the answer to this central question relate to the main theme and message of Hamlet? If an open prompt asks you to answer how something "affects the work as whole", you have to include the main theme of the work. Otherwise, great job! Great job in being detailed.
Katie,
ReplyDeleteYour introduction is well done and introductions are pretty hard so great job. I think that starting with a question definitely drew my attention and with an AP reader it could be the same. Your summaries, which are not really summaries, are useful and you do not just use them to fill space but they are there to help support your points. The conclusion ends with the question again, bringing it full circle was also a good technique to use. I agree with Debra, I think that you could expand more on the question about the whole work. Even though your details were great and I felt like you did have a good grasp on the play, making sure to tie in the idea of the theme of Hamlet and the whole work. Other than that I think this is a great response! Especially the introduction!