Sunday, October 20, 2013

Open Prompts, Part One. Examples 3A, 3B and 3C


Prompt: Many writers use a country setting to establish values within a work of literature.  For example, the country may be a place of virtue and peace or one of primitivism and ignorance.  Choose a novel or play in which such a setting plays a significant role.  Then write an essay in which you analyze how the country setting functions in the work as a whole.

3A:
This essay is very impressive.  Especially after doing a practice prompt I understand how hard it can be to write these essays.  One of the most important things and also can be the hardest is making sure you’re answering the prompt and this author does an amazing job of this.  The author also explained a lot about the book, which I thought was very helpful. I have never read Jane Austen’s Persuasion but with all the examples I can tell that it works great with the prompt.  She did a great job of backing up all of her statements with information from the book.  For example she said, “Only in this country setting is Anne held in a superior light, for her qualities of intelligence, kindness and modesty are held in high regard here.”  This is just such a well-written sentence and overall it is enjoyable to read.  The conclusion does a great job of summing everything up nicely as well.  The only complaint I would have would be all the grammar errors.

3B:
In this essay we can tell that the author was trying very hard with lots of different details but he or she failed to find a deeper meaning to it all.  The author says a lot of important facts such as, “it is written in dialect,” but these statements fail to relate back to the actual question, which is the most important thing.  Everything said has to be justified by the question.  However, I know that these are not easy to write and I think he or she came up with a good example of The Importance of Being Earnest.   It is also really nicely written and easy to read; which is always a plus considering some people’s handwritingJ I think the author could have also done a better job of tying his of her thesis back into the conclusion, since we want to remember what the author is arguing for.  Overall, it is a pretty average essay that had some nice components but also could use a lot of improvement. 

3C:
This essay definitely could have been written and brainstormed better.   The author is almost cocky in the essay thinking that he or she knows everything without using any evidence to back up all of the claims.  There are a lot of details about the plot, which is helpful but then it started to become more of a summary than an essay with examples.  For instance the writer says, “Why else would she give herself sexually twice thinking that the second would reverse the effects of the first?”  First of all, this sentence does not even really make sense and it is assuming a lot of things.  Everyone can have different opinions about topics and this author comes off as rude.  I think he or she is trying to be funny, which is good sometimes but not throughout the whole essay.   In conclusion this author had the right idea but needed a lot more focus on the prompt and examples.

3 comments:

  1. Katie,
    This really is a solid post, a good benchmark for anyone looking for such. Your concision did not take away from your analysis and your use of examples was appropriate, though, you might've wanted to put a few more in, just to further reinforce the points being made. Otherwise, I think this post is just fine and that you should keep doing what you're doing with these kinds of posts.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Katie,
    Good job analyzing these three essays. You made some good points in you analysis of essay 3A. I also have not read Jane Austen’s Persuasion and agree that the explanation provided by the essayist helped me understand the argument, but I felt there was almost too much explanation (at least for my liking there was too much book summary). Your discussion of essay 3B was very good and I felt it was your best of the three (though they were all good). In this analysis I feel you really looked at it critically; you said “Everything said has to be justified by the question” and “[it is important to tie the] thesis back into the conclusion, since we want to remember what the author is arguing for”. These two points you made show that you are really thinking about the writing and structure of these essays, which can only help you in May. The analysis you did of 3C was also great, and I thought your interpretation of the authors tone and attitude coming through was correct, I saw them as cocky and rude too. Great job on these analyses Katie!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Katie,
    We wrote about the same essays! How crazy convenient.
    You pointed out all of the important things I thought were central to the critique of the various essays, such as the author of the third essay’s snarky tone and the good amount of evidence the one of the first essay included in his analysis. Good job with this; you obviously had a good understanding of what is being asked of us to take from this blog assignment.
    As for your overall critique of the essays, you did well in making sure you had evidence to back up your points. Being that some readers of your posts might not have actually read the essays about which you write, evidence and a description of the prompt are important to have, so good job including those. All in all, marvelous job of analyzing the essays!

    ReplyDelete