Wednesday, October 23, 2013

Response to Course Material #2


Since reading and discussing The American Dream we have read Death of a Salesman.  While watching the movie I did not find the story line that entertaining or interesting at all.  I even started to wonder why we were even reading the book.  But once I actually got a chance to read the book and analyze it I found myself loving it.  I caught on to all of these implications and foreshadowing that I did not while I was watching the movie.  I have been much more involved in the discussion of this book then normal because I felt like I understood it a lot more than The American Dream.  I feel like I can relate a lot to Biff because although my dad is not insane he can be pretty annoying and sometimes I just want to get away.  When I was younger I idolized my dad like Biff did but as I got older I realized he was not perfect, just as Biff did.  I also did a lot better on my annotations of the book because now that we are pretty far along in the year I know the literary terms a lot better and I can actually apply them.   This is pretty cool for me because I feel like I have learned so much and am also enjoying the class a lot.

Besides just reading Death of A Salesman, we have also done a close reading of the poem Promises Like Piecrust.  I really enjoyed this poem because I feel like it is so true.  Promises are broken most of the time and it is scary to jump into a commitment.  I do think that you should take the risk and make commitments though.  I try not to live my life in fear and understand that I am going to get hurt at some point.  Overall this was a really fun poem to talk about since everyone had such different opinions about it.    Going along with this poem we got to write AP essay prompts, which I found to be really eye opening.  I actually found it a little challenging.  It made me realize how much work goes into just writing the prompt so that they get the response they want.  It was a fun activity to get to swap them with another group though. 

In conclusion over the past few works I feel like I have really improved and participated more which was my goal.  I’m starting to enjoy the class a lot more and feeling more comfortable with my peers.  I am excited to read more books and learning even more.  I know that everyday I am getting more and more prepared for the AP test at the end of the year!

4 comments:

  1. Great job making connections, and pretty thorough coverage--the only thing you really missed was our coverage of the forms of tragedy.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Katie,
    I really enjoyed the fact that you connected "Death of a Salesman" with your own life, something that I speculatively think few of us did. You were able to bring in your own personal experiences with your father and draw quite a clear line between your life and the play, so good job with that. Everything else in the post was fine, it really outlined your experiences and views on this whole class, but I would like to hear your thoughts on tragedy and if "Death of a Salesman" qualifies as a "true" tragedy, or just your thoughts on tragedy in general. I think that as we progress into the year and we begin to read "Hamlet" that the idea of tragedy will become very prominent in all our thoughts, as "Hamlet" is the benchmark for tragedy.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Katie,
    First of all, though I enjoyed your analysis of the piece, I would advise you to go through and review your grammar and sentence structure. I think doing so would allow a better understanding of your post for future reference.
    In general, though, you did hit all of the profound things we discussed in class. As Mrs. Holmes and Drew pointed out, though, you would do well to touch on tragic elements as well. Perhaps bring up the various in-class readings we did to support whatever claims you decide to bring up in your post. Make connections between the traditional definition of literary tragedy and the one that Miller invokes in DoS. This is an important point that was brought up—at least in my class—and I think it would be a useful thing to have for when you review this post later on.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Katie,
    I loved this post! I thought it was great how you connected Death of a Salesman back to your own life, especially to someone as close to you as your dad. I like how you pointed out that you understand this play better than The American Dream and so you contributed to the discussion more this time, I wish you would say more during discussions because you do have great things to say and I especially liked discussing with you during fishbowl discussions. Your comments on Promises like Pie-Crust and writing the AP prompt were fun to read, though I had fun coming up with an essay prompt and found it relatively easy. I also enjoyed see another group’s response and interpretation of my prompt was very entertaining. Like Drew I am interested in whether or not you think Death of a Salesman can be considered a tragedy, either by the traditional definition or by a newer one. Great post Katie!

    ReplyDelete