Sunday, November 17, 2013

Open Prompt #3


Prompt:  Choose a novel, or play, write an essay in which you analyze a central question the work raises and the extent to which it offers answers.  Explain how the author's treatment of this question affects your understanding of the work as a whole.  Avoid mere plot summary.

1.  Overall this essay does a very nice job of answering the prompt in an organized and detailed manner.  The student chooses to talk about the novel Candide, which I have never heard of before, but he or she does a nice job of explaining how the author answers the central question of, "Why would God create a world that is not the best possible?" while also adding information from the novel to better help the readers understand.  The student even offers quotes from the books, which is really impressive that he or she could remember the exact quotes without having the book in front of them.  These quotes really add a lot to the idea that the student had a true understanding of the novel.  One thing that the writer could improve on is straying from the topic in the conclusion.  He or she goes on to talking about another book saying, "for as Kahlil Gibrar states in The Prophet loving also entails pain."  Although this may be true, he or she should focus on how the novel he or she choose answers the central question.  Overall this is a pretty impressive essay and I would probably give it an 8!

2.  This student writes about The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn.  He or she does a nice job of getting to the point of stating the central question and then talk about how it is answered but the claims are pretty weak.  In the opening paragraph, the student simply states the central question and offers no other thoughts or information.  Yes, he or she answered the question of addressing the central question but it could have been developed a lot better.  For example he or she says, "It is on the raft the Jim and Huff can build a friendship."  Personally I found this essay to just be a summary of the book with a central question thrown in at the beginning and a decent conclusion.  I did not find any evidence that the central question affected his of her understanding of the novel.  Also there are so many mistakes in the essay.  Every other word is crossed out and a new one is written in.  This shows that he or she did not know what he or she wanted to say.  The student should have spent more time organizing his or her ideas before starting the essay.  Overall this essay does address the prompt but fails to offer a good explanation of the central question.  I would give it a 4.

3.  This last essay could definitely use a lot of help.  The student wrote about the novel Things Fall Apart but does not even mention a central question.  Considering the prompt asks you to analyze the central question, the student could not receive a good score even if the essay was written really well.  Let me just tell you though it is not well written.  The student made very vague claims such as, "whether they were small or major changes, they always happen."  First of all the grammar in this sentence does not make sense and also there are no references from the book after this to back it up.  I found myself quite frustrated while reading this essay because the grammar was so bad and there was no organization.  This essay also only has one body paragraph with very few details and it is hard to receive a good score with such little analysis.  Overall I do not think the student had a good understanding of the prompt or the novel he or she was talking about.  Because of the lack of analysis and failure to answer the prompt, I would give it a 2.  

5 comments:

  1. Katie,
    Sorry to be the bearer of bad news, but you have done a closed prompt instead of an open prompt. Yes, these things can be confusing...it took me some time to figure out what one(open prompt) was. Every third question for every year is an open prompt. This prompt that you chose is a closed prompt because it asks the students to analyze two poems. An open prompt should be broad. With that being said and done, as I read your thoughts you did well in noticing the errors that each student makes. Consider how each student uses techniques to better their essays. And if you disagree with the AP Reader's commentary it would make for an interesting paragraph if you said so and explain your reasoning for so. Also, provide the scores so your readers understand how badly the student failed... and especially when they wrote brilliantly. Providing these examples will help your readers to be even more focused and aware. In your second paragraph you mention that the essay contains a lot of quotes, but that the student doesn't provide any evidence...unless I've misunderstood you, do you mean that with the evidence provided-the quotes- that they don't add to the student's claim. Like they're unnecessary fillers?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Katie, as Ludia stated your did a closed prompt. Don't worry, I did this three times in a row.. embarrassing I know. So no worries. Third question, as Ludia pointed out is often an Open prompt. Each student should be writing about a DIFFERENT book/example. From evaluating this piece, it looks good. Just remember evidence, evidence, evidence! Keep up the good work:)

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Katie,
    Everyone else already covered the open vs. close prompt thing, so I won't bother with that. (I've made that mistake twice already, so no worries) It appears, however, that your critiques are well written and very inclusive. You address important ideas such as whether or not the students address the prompt and include proper literary devices in their essays, which is important. The only thing I would suggest though is adding a bit more evidence from the essays themselves. It can be tedious, I know, but including ample evidence seems to get us more points and helps the reader better comprehend what we are writing when we address the sample essays. Other than that though, excellent work!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Wow thanks guys! I had no idea I was doing it wrong until you'll let me know. I re did this blog to an open prompt and I made sure I did my next one as an open prompt! Thanks!

    ReplyDelete