http://www.lansingstatejournal.com/article/20131102/OPINION01/311020015/Editorial-roundup-NSA-eroded-trust-U-S-allies
This is an article about the US being
caught spying of "three dozen world leaders" (Herald.) Everyone
has heard different things about what actually happened and how much President
Obama knew about it, but the truth is hard to find. The author uses
specific details, eye-opening imagery and short sentences (syntax) to inform
the public of the sad but true facts about this.
The author is not afraid to report all of
the details on this topic. It allows the audience to understand the
actual facts and knowing these facts makes the US government look pretty bad.
Before reading this article many Americans may not have thought it was
that big of a deal but when everyone reads details such as, "the White
House at first denied the accusations. Then it
offered a belated mea culpa that admitted little and satisfied few"
(Herald.) To find out that the government at first tried to lie about
this and then just admitted little is shocking. These details have caused many Americans to lose trust in
the government.
The author’s use of imagery
hits the readers even more than even the details. The author does an impressive job of painting an image in
the readers’ minds of how big of a deal this spying actually is. Two sentences that really sticks out is
when the author says, “Consider how Americans would
react if they discovered that Germany tapped President Obama’s cellphone or
that France monitored millions of Americans’ phone calls. We would demand
action and accountability, just as they have demanded from us” (Herald.) This is such a true statement hits home
hard. It’s crazy to think of the
outrage that would happen if Americans discovered people were listening in on
Americans’ calls. This imagery
does a great job allowing the public to understand the truth and basically
putting them against the government.
Lastly the author’s use of syntax
with a lot of short sentences displays action, which makes the readers feel
like the information is that much more important. When the author makes short intense statements, its shocks
the readers and forces the readers to continue reading since the readers cannot
believe what has just been said. A
great example of this is when the author says, “Edward Snowden is a traitor”
and “Edward Snowden is a heroic leaker” (Herald.) These short sentences also help the author show the “he-said,
she-said” that is going on right now.
People are saying many different things and Americans have had trouble
discovering the actual truth. By
the author writing these short and such accusatory sentences that make the
readers read on, the author can then write the truth later on that makes most
Americans furious.
The authors use of harsh but true
details, intense imagery and short intense sentences force the readers to
realize what a big dealt this is and how bad it is that the government tried to
cover it up. Without these uses of
techniques the readers may not have thought it was that outrageous and just
kept allowing the government to do these things without calling the government
out for what has been done.
Katie,
ReplyDeleteNice essay format. I don't have much to critique other than your imagery paragraph. Personally I don't feel like the sentence you provided displayed much imagery. If anything the imagery here is weak. Sure, I see countries, but they're blobs with the labels "Germany" and "France". My question is who is doing this phone tapping? Give me the names of the people! Not you, the writer. The writer might be specific with the hypothetical question, but he/she is far from specific in the creative details that make up imagery, allowing the reader to be aware of the magnitude of this situation. What I'm seeing is what I would imagine if I were to rewrite this sentence. Okay, I'm being picky but ugh, if feels more like the writer is providing more detail-based sentences here.
Katie, I loved your essay structure here. You have a strong intro, summarizing the article, followed by 3 body paragraphs (each of your claims) and a conclusion. This made it very easy for me to read and evaluate. I don't have much to say about your work, as far as critiques go. I think you did a really great job backing your claims up with evidence. The only thing I could say, is maybe include a couple more quotes/examples from the article. I especially liked your syntax paragraph and you quote "Edward Snowden is a traitor" and "Edward snowden is a heroic leaker." This was a great example to show the bias in this piece. One last caution is to try to not instill your own personal opinion on the issue, however, I don't disagree with what you have said, focus more on the bias on this piece. Overall, good job!
ReplyDeleteKatie,
ReplyDeleteYour thesis statement in this essay was very nicely worded. I find it hard to find the correct, concise way to write these in the various pieces we write in this class, so I applaud you for writing yours so successfully. As for your details paragraph, I would suggest adding more of your thoughts on the author's use of them within its writing than the details themselves. That is, how did it reveal these details to the readers? Gradually, or all at once for a dramatic effect? I think it is things like this we are supposed to focus on. I could be wrong of course, this is merely a suggestions. Your syntax paragraph was nicely done, and you included good, relevant quotes to support your claims. I especially liked the way you wrote the essay itself; your voice was admirable and very pleasant to read.