Michelle Obama, mom in chief
In this article, the author defends Michelle Obama of
exhibiting “frightening behaviors” (Milbank). The New York Times reported that she has been “derided by
critics who hoped she would use her historic position to move more deeply into
policy.” The author used comical
diction, specific syntax and interesting details to show how even though the
First Lady is spending most of her time talking about gingerbread houses that
that is the smart choice.
Milbank’s use of comical diction allow the readers to
understand how crazy it is that the First Lady is more worried about decorating
the White House than making an actual impact while she has the power. Many would have expected her to try to make
a change now that her husband has been reelected but instead she is taking on
the conventional role of playing “mom.”
The author uses words such as, “hullabaloo” and “debacle” to describe
what would happen if she “install(ed) herself as a lightening rod atop the
White House” (Milbank). The author
could have chosen to use serious words to describe why the First Lady might not
be trying to make use of her power but instead he goes along with the story by
using funny words since all the things she has been doing are comical.
Milbank uses specific syntax to sway the readers into
understanding the situation that Mrs. Obama is in. In the beginning of the article he uses short sentences such
as, “the feminist nightmare is reoccurring” to cue the readers into what the
First Lady is being portrayed as.
Later on in the article when he is defending her actions and explaining
why she is acting like an old-fashioned woman, longer sentences are used. Short sentences portray action and
excitement. When readers start to
read the article it forces them to continue reading since they are so intrigued
by these short intense sentences.
Once the author has gotten the reader to read on, he can use long
sentences such as, “were she to follow her critics’ advice now that her husband is safely
reelected and install herself as a lightning rod atop the White House, the
resulting hullabaloo would sap whatever focus remains on the Obama policy
agenda.” These longer sentences do
a better job of explaining the situation to the readers.
Lastly the author uses interesting details to get the
readers hooked on the story and then make it seem like Mrs. Obama has no other
choice but to act as mom in chief.
The author could have decided not to include the details about all the
crazy things she has been doing recently to help him defend her but instead he
reports on these items and then gives rational explanations. This makes the article seem more
creditable since it shows all the facts.
For example when he writes, “she spoke of Christmas trees made from
stacks of books and described the first dog display featuring likenesses of Bo
and Sunny” the readers are astonished at how ridiculous that is but then by
including more details later in the article about how she has to play this role
readers are more likely to understand.
The author’s impressive use of comical diction, specific
syntax and interesting details used let the readers feel like they are hearing
the whole truth while also being persuaded that this is what the First Lady
should be doing.
Katie, this is a great analysis of this article. You provided several specific examples to portray the main point the author was trying to make. I found this article very interesting, for often times I wonder about people who hold great power but are somewhat abusing it and do not use it to benefit others. I think this article is a very interesting take of Michele Obama's actions, you explain that the author is clearly defending her actions, so does this mean that the author is justifying her actions as being good that she is acting like the "mom in chief?" If so, I can't decide if I agree or not with this opinion. What is your stand on it? This is a very interesting article, and overall you did a great job of describing how the author used DIDLS. Good work!
ReplyDeleteKatie,
ReplyDeleteSo far, I think that this is your best blog post. I have a hard time giving it any criticism what so ever. I loved how you showed rather than told. The only thing that I would ask you do is show some opinion. Did you like the article? Do you think that the Author’s use of comical diction was used well? Other than that, there isn’t really anything else to pick at. I loved how you used quotes to show how the author uses syntax, and I liked that you used the one longer quote to show how the long sentences help get the point across. I liked how you showed how the author used DIDLES but I think that its also important to show some opinion.
Katie,
ReplyDeleteMy only qualm with this post would be your conclusion, which, for me, left me wanting more. Let me say that I know how difficult it is to write an effective conclusion; in all honesty, I still don't know how to do it perfectly every time, and sometimes the fatigue of writing an effective body saps all ideas for a working conclusion. Not to say your conclusion doesn't work, I just think that it only restates the thesis and the body. A good conclusion, I've been told, should do more than just restate the prompt or thesis or body, it should help to re-synthesize the point of the essay. Often times, a conclusion extends what was written in the body and leaves the reader with something to think about; and how to write a conclusion that does that is tricky. I've maybe only written one conclusion in my life that does anything close to that. On the surface, though, I would say to lengthen the conclusion from one sentence to several, just so the essay doesn't end so abruptly. And hey, I don't even have that down; in all honesty I'd rather just stick a little blunt ending on everything and leave it at that. But the literature gods have decreed that we must write something insightful at the end of everything, so they give us all, as writers, something to work on.