So it is officially break...yay! We have to do this response to course material so I figured I might as well just get it done. I think the last time I posted a response like this we had just started with Hamlet. I remember thinking that I was never going to have a good understanding of it and the class discussions would not be as good since less people understand it. I now know that I was wrong though. With the help of Ms. Holmes clueing us in on some important background information or things we would have missed we have ended up having some really interesting discussions. We have also watched I think about 6 different versions of Hamlet. I liked different things about different ones. I cannot remember what the versions were called but I really liked the ones where the ghost was portrayed as real. I always saw the ghost as real and good, not evil. I really enjoyed the modern version though since it was something I could relate to better and understand. It was still cool to see the versions that went right off the text to though since that is how it would have been performed originally. We did spend quite a lot of time watching these films but I felt like it was very beneficiary. It allowed us to think about things like how important sticking to the original text is and if the ghost is real. Overall I really enjoyed Hamlet. Yes, it was a tragedy but I really felt for Hamlet since I do not think anyone could really understand what he was going through. He was my favorite character even though he did kinda go crazy.
Besides spending most of our time watching and discussing Hamlet, we have done a few other activities. We talked about how Shakespeare took ideas from ancient stories such as Amleth. This story had many similarities to Hamlet and we even realized that if you stick the h at the end of Amleth in the front it spells Hamlet...that's so crazy!! I guess even the greatest of writers do not come up with everything on their own:) We also had a homework reading and annotating the article "Tragic Balance in Hamlet." The next day while discussing this we found that the writer trying to use such elevated diction kind of took away from the ideas that he was trying to say. I agreed with him on some things like the idea of faith but a lot of his ideas I found to be confusing.
Well I am sure I might have missed an activity or two that we have done but those are the important things that I can remember. Okay now I can go enjoy my break:)
Katie, great job covering everything we have done the last month in class! Now it's a little hard to relate to everything because it was so long ago, but this has definitely refreshed my memory. I also liked the modern film the most, also because it was the easiest to relate to. I also still enjoyed the films that more in line with the time age that Hamlet originally took place in. I think the modern films seemed more for enjoyment while the others that stuck closer to the original story were more for understanding purposes. It's crazy to think how many interpretations there are of Hamlet. Which one do you agree with the most or think could be the possible 'real story?' It's also interesting to see how similar Hamlet was to Hamlet, it's interesting to think that most stories stem from other's ideas, even if it just subconsciously. The article we read and annotated did do a good job of displaying how elevated diction is not necessary, for still to this day I don't think I understood that article completely or even know the main point of it. Overall, great analysis and posts, they were very insightful!
ReplyDeleteKatie,
ReplyDeleteI liked how you said why you liked the modern Hamlets better than the older ones, and why you like Hamlet better than other characters. I think you missed some pretty big points though. The first thing is how each version of Hamlet was preformed. Yes there were a ton of Hamlets, and after a while it gets repetitive and boring, but each version had some good points to ponder. For example the relationships between character in each film is drastically different. How do the differences help you to understand Hamlet? Which of the films do you agree with the most? I think in the first paragraph of your post you said that you liked different things from all of them, but what does that mean? Do you like the funny pants? Or do you think that showing Ophelia in a straight jacket lying on the ground is a good way to portray her madness. You’ve got some good stuff in this post, but I think if you answered just a few of these questions, it would make a world of a difference.
Katie,
ReplyDeleteI know many of us in our hour certainly share the same opinion as you, but you were the only one I've seen write it out on a post, your opinion being that Hamlet is "pretty crazy." Personally, I do not think Hamlet was every truly "mad" or "crazy"; I believe that his "madness" is merely a cloak that conceals who he really is and what his true intentions are from Claudius and Gertrude, who he does not trust. However, I must counter myself in saying that I don't believe every instance of his madness was calculated, especially when he jumps into Ophelia's grave in a fit of passion. But, most instances of his supposed madness, I believe, are expressions of the reappearing motif of two-facedness. I would like to hear more about your opinion on the matter, though, for discussing such things is what AP Lit and literature in general is all about.