Saturday, October 12, 2013

Close Reading #2


Article: It’s Not Only Mothers and Children


In the editorial, It’s Not Only Mothers and Children, the author writes how normally people think of families being in poverty because the parents are unable to provide for the kids when in reality most of the people living in poverty are childless adults.  The author explains how difficult it is to get Medicaid these days and how it needs to be extended to childless, low-income adults but many Republican states are not agreeing to this.  The author’s use of long sentences, specific details and colloquial diction give a strong feeling that something needs to be done to help all of the childless adults, living in poverty that do not qualify for Medicaid.

The author’s use of long sentences force the audience to keep reading.  Although sometimes people can get bored with long sentences the author does a nice job of mixing in some average size sentences to not let the readers get too lost.  Since the article is about such a serious topic, using long sentences was definitely the best choice since the author needed to put in so much information.  The author starts off the article saying, “for impoverished Americans, the biggest obstacle to health insurance remains the refusal of 26 mostly Republican-led states to expand their Medicaid programs as called for under the health reform law.”  This is a mouth full to take in but is eye opening to the audience to read.  Using long sentences was ultimately the reason this editorial came off as so informative and persuasive, since the long sentences were so well written.

The author’s use of specific details allows the readers to assume that the author knows the actual facts and that the information must be true.  By using details such as, “most, however, are childless adults, generally defined as those age 19 to 64 without dependent children.”  This sentence suggests that the author actually did a lot of research for the article, which makes the readers agree with what is being said, since it seems legitimate.  Also the fact that the author uses such harsh details about the Republicans not wanting to add the reform makes the audience sympathize with the childless adults living in poverty even more.  Without this use of such harsh and specific details the author would not have nearly as many people agreeing with him.

Lastly the author’s use of colloquial diction makes this a very easy article to understand and read.  Sometimes when such high language is used people will get confused and not want to read an article.  With everyday language being used though, everyone is willing to read it and does not get lost or bored.  The author knew to get the point across that simple yet detailed sentences would be best.  This colloquial diction also makes the readers feel more involved in the issue.

Overall, without the authors use of long sentences, specific details and colloquial diction this article would not be effective.  These were great techniques to use to allow the public to be more educated about this issue.  The techniques also make everyone want to do something about the matter.

4 comments:

  1. Katie--You've done well with the first part of this essay, but in the final support paragraph, you offer only assertions and warrants--no actual evidence. This is especially a problem because in your September peer critique it was pointed out that you don't always clearly distinguish between "diction" and "language," and when you say "The author knew to get the point across that simple yet detailed sentences would be best," I see this warrant as really talking about syntax.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Katie,
    You've hit on something here that anyone writing about politics should realize, and that is that facts are always the best persuasive element. The details the author included were the biggest factor in helping this essay's purpose along, which you explained very well. But like Mrs. Holmes said, I think you should work on differentiating between things like "language" and "diction", as they are separate in this class. Language is figurative language that helps push a piece along and create interest and images in the writing, while diction is the actual word choice of the author. I think next time that you'll be able to see the difference and use the words appropriately though.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Katie,
    I feel that you did a pretty good job analyzing this article. This article is not a simple article, so the elements of DIDLS are harder to find, though you did a fairly good job finding them. Your analysis of the author’s use of long sentences was great; you’re spot on when you say that the long sentences helped get the point of the article across. I completely agree with you that the author’s use of harsh and specific details cause the readers to sympathize with the childless adults. Also, your assumption that the use of specific details gives legitimacy to the article is correct—when reading the article, I definitely believed that writer knew what they were talking about. Now I hate to say this and sound repetitive, as Drew and Ms. Holmes have both already said this, but your paragraph on diction was weak. I can understand if there was confusion on the difference between diction and language (I still mix them up a bit), but I think that next time you will definitely have the difference down. Overall a successful post, good job Katie!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Katie,
    I commend you for your analysis of the article you chose; being that it was from the New York Times and an editorial, it is a bit more difficult to pinpoint DIDLS, but you did so well. Personally, I tend to search for more artsy article on sites like Slate and McSweeny’s because they provide far more evidence that make blog writing much easier. I would highly recommend them.
    Anyway, I think that you could better back up a few of the claims you make within the post. For example, when you bring up evidence from the text— “By using details such as, “most, however, are childless adults, generally defined as those age 19 to 64 without dependent children.” — you do not quite “embed” the quote in the way that is usually done in essays. Rather than just throwing it in there as evidence of detail, your position would be more credible and easier to follow if you lead into the quote a bit more and then fully explain why it works to back up your ideas. Just a suggestion.
    Well done!

    ReplyDelete